It’s the 243rd celebration of American independence from British tyranny. Do you know where your democracy is? Under the colored contrails of six Blue Angels, a nation turns its jaundiced eyes to a display of patriotism worthy of NASCAR.
In a parody of Bastille Day partially paid for with cash pilfered from U.S. Park Service fees, Washington’s self-styled Royal Family found itself on the hunt for its inner Louis XVI just before the guillotine was rolled out.
Just as there is considerable doubt that Donald Trump knows the words to “The Star-Spangled Banner” or could recite the Pledge of Allegiance without considerable prompting, no one believes that Mr. Trump has a clue about the radical politics behind the storming of the Bastille in 1789 and why France continues to celebrate it annually with Europe’s largest military parade.
What Mr. Trump saw during his visit to Paris during Bastille Day a year ago filled him with envy of a Western power’s embrace of what looked like Napoleonic-levels of militarism to his ahistorical eyes.
With little knowledge of French history and even less about the intersection of its armies and populist revolutions over the centuries, Mr. Trump wants America going forward to imitate what he believes to be France’s unashamed celebration of the militaristic state.
For Mr. Trump, patriotism on the Fourth of July has less to do with the preservation of democratic ideals and a non-partisan holiday that all Americans can embrace than ensuring the shininess of our weapons as they rumble behind hundreds of active-duty soldiers marching the length of the Washington Mall for his aggrandizement.
Read More
Mr. Trump doesn’t know or understand that democracy can’t be found in the ostentatious display of firepower on the Mall. It can’t be found in the boastful tweets of an insecure commander-in-chief, either.
Democracy isn’t in the mindless chants of “USA, USA, USA” that have become the last refuge of scoundrels at the president’s rallies. Democracy can’t be found in the demonizing of migrants, asylum seekers or children housed in subhuman conditions at the border or in normalizing the rhetoric of xenophobia.
The 243rd celebration of the nation’s independence should not be a nostalgic look back at an America that never existed. The American victory over the British was not based on our military prowess alone. The Continental Army, as the “Hamilton” soundtrack reminds us, was “out-gunned / out-manned /out-numbered / out-planned.”
What the 243rd celebration should be about, even if the country hasn’t always lived up to the creed it espouses, is the persistence of the idea of a republic of the self-governed.
We should not become a republic of fear. We should not allow ourselves to become a people afraid of our own shadows. We should not allow ourselves to become a democracy in decline because flattery of a popinjay president demands it.
What is the point of showing off Abrams tanks and Bradley Fighting Vehicles when so many veterans of recent wars live on the streets or migrate to homeless shelters and soup kitchens daily?
What is the point of showing off precision fighter jets when schools across America are underfunded, infrastructure is collapsing and low-information citizens are more skeptical than ever about the value of democracy?
Why celebrate something as superficial as how many nuclear missiles we have if our democracy is more vulnerable to foreign hacking and manipulation than ever? Who is Mr. Trump really trying to impress with such vain and gaudy displays of military readiness?
Next year, America will undergo what will likely be the nastiest election campaign in American history because the stakes are so high. It won’t matter who the Democratic nominee will be — he or she will be running against powerful incumbent headwinds. The Democratic ticket will also be going up against a ruthless Republican political machine that knows something about holding onto and exercising power even as its majorities shrink.
Despite his bad poll numbers, the assumption should be that Mr. Trump has more supporters than may be comfortable admitting their enthusiasm to pollsters.
I don’t think this means Mr. Trump will be rewarded with a second term, but I do believe his supporters will turn out, possibly in larger numbers than in 2016, especially if they think their “champion” is facing a humiliating rebuke by the voters. There really are more Americans who agree with Mr. Trump than are reflected in the polls, so they could make a difference.
There are also more Americans who are disturbed by the hijacking of our democracy than have expressed their disgust at the polls to date. I believe this sleeping giant is finally stirring, and will put the critics of the president in the majority in both the electoral college and the popular vote.
The 2020 election will be a better barometer of where our democracy stands than a militarized Fourth of July that managed to push a non-partisan fireworks display honoring this country from the Mall.
Next year, on the first presidential election following the nation’s 244th birthday, America will know beyond the sophistry of political spin whether it is a democracy or not.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.