Baraboo, Wis., is like many towns in the Upper Midwest. It is 94 percent white and not particularly bothered by its ethnic insularity. Thanks to good schools, strong families and wholesome traditions, life in the town of 12,000 is about as Middle America as the cliche gets.
As per its wholesome traditions, a group of high school boys in their Sunday best gathered on the steps of the Sauk County Courthouse last spring to be photographed by family and friends.
The group photos of the boys, a mix of juniors and seniors, is an annual part of the community’s pre-prom ritual of niceness, though it takes place far from the high school and is not under its supervision.
That will probably change if what happened this past spring is any indication. This week, a photo of more than 60 Baraboo High School students was posted on social media. Taken by the school’s former football coach and featured prominently on his photography studio website, the picture showed most of the students with their arms in the air, giving what many living in the real world believe to be Nazi salutes.
“We even got the black kid to throw it up” boasted one tweet with the hashtag #barabooproud. There is, indeed, one black kid in the second row on the far right, but his face and arm position are partially obscured by the enthusiastic Hitler salute of the kid standing in front of him to his right.
The photographer, Peter Gust, claimed that the provocative picture was the result of “a brain fart” that had resulted from his instruction to the boys. He told reporters he asked the boys to “give me a high sign, a wave that you’re saying goodbye to your parents.”
Now, unless their parents are Mr. and Mrs. Adolf Eichmann, most kids don’t typically “wave” goodbye in the same way German soldiers saluted their commanding officers as they marched off to the Russian front.
Alas, Mr. Gust, the former Baraboo High football coach turned professional photographer, now claims he caught the students in that awkward millisecond between an innocent bent armed wave and the stiff-armed pledge of allegiance of Hitler Youth circa 1938.
Really, such unfortunate timing could happen to anyone and was totally inadvertent according to Mr. Gust. When he put the photo on his website, it didn’t strike Mr. Gust as offensive.
The camera caught a kid in the center of the front row who, ironically, wasn’t making the salute that would later embarrass his classmates, though he was making the equally noxious upside down “OK” sign popular with white supremacists.
Sure, it could’ve been a scene straight out of “The Boys from Brazil,” but the parents of some of the young men insist there’s been a terrible misunderstanding and that their stiff-armed offspring aren’t Nazis, racists or white supremacists.
In the Nuremberg Trial of public opinion, such protestations are a hard sell. Still, I eagerly look forward to the day one of the boys in the photo comes forward with the excuse: “I was only following the photographer’s orders.”
One young man has contradicted the photographer’s story that the photo represented an “innocent” fraction of a second caught at the most awkward moment possible. Jordan Blue, who stood on the fourth step on the far right of the photograph, is the one wearing a red bow tie and appearing to say to himself: “These idiots are screwed. Bye, bye Harvard.”
Mortified by what his classmates were doing, Jordan kept his arms down and his conscience clean. He says that, yeah, what his classmates did was intentional — but in that jokey way that kids with zero perspective about World War II or the Holocaust joke about saluting Hitler and being Nazis.
Still, the photograph didn’t become a big deal until it began circulating on social media this week. Once the story got out, it made headlines around the world.
Yet, to the parents and members of the Baraboo community who have been aware of the photo for months, it somehow didn’t occur to them that seeing so many white faces smiling while saluting like Nazis could be interpreted as an affirmation of bigotry and anti-Semitism given the uptick in racial hatred across the country in recent years.
“We know many of these boys,” Marcy Huffaker, a former Sauk County Board member told reporters covering the story. “We do not know them to be racist or full of hate. But it’s impossible to think that some of them didn’t know what they were doing.”
Still, 25 percent of all anti-Semitic incidents recorded in Wisconsin last year took place among students or on campuses, according to the Jewish Federation of Madison, which has been closely monitoring the controversy this week.
Some of the boys in the photograph, no matter how innocent they may appear to parents, teachers and community leaders, could be responsible for some of those intolerant acts. The photo just puts faces to such cowardly actions.
If we didn’t live at a time when even the president of the United States finds it difficult to unequivocally condemn white nationalists, it might have been possible to give Nazi-saluting students the benefit of the doubt for a second. Doing that would be ridiculous now after Charlottesville and Pittsburgh. Now, we can only marvel at the gullibility of the banal and ask ourselves, like the character in the Talking Heads song, “Well, how did we get here?”
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.