A little more than a year ago, I met with my friend, editorial cartoonist Rob Rogers, over beers in Regent Square. There was nothing on the agenda other than a casual hang with a fellow liberal to commiserate over an election that still felt shocking weeks later.
Neither one of us was sure how the election would affect us professionally. At one point, I turned to Rob and jokingly proposed a mutual defense pact. If anything would happen to him, then I would quit, or get fired, too (and vice versa).
I don’t remember how Rob reacted to my quip, but I’m sure neither of us could envision a realistic scenario in which one of the most popular editorial cartoonists in the business would have anything to worry about, despite the editorial page’s rightward slant. Rob was too valuable a national brand.
Last week, that “brand” was handed a severance package and asked to turn in his building access pass. When I read about it in a tweet he sent out shortly after it happened, I was stunned.
The public reaction was epic and predictable, as was the reaction of PG staff. Though furious and brokenhearted, many of us took to social media to argue that cancelling one’s subscription because of fear that a “pro-Trump agenda” would infest the news side was misguided.
We, too, grieved Rob’s firing, but the PG’s ongoing journalistic mission was bigger than even our marquee editorial cartoonist’s enormous talent.
Some readers wondered whether I would now have to write columns that reflected a pro-Trump party-line as a price for continued employment at the PG. I told them not to worry. PG columnists, like those at any good newspaper, write from their convictions; editors do not dictate our politics. Our integrity means more to us than a spot on the Perspectives page and a paycheck. Our opinion section has always published a wide spectrum of views.
Believe it or not, there was a time when Rob’s cartoons generated more controversy outside the editorial suites of the PG than inside. Though an unabashed liberal by trade and temperament, Rob Rogers was often accused of racism, anti-Catholic bigotry and harboring sympathy for terrorists by humorless mobs of self-appointed art critics in the public. No one, not even me, got more hate mail than this guy.
On at least two occasions, I felt compelled to write refutations against ridiculous charges that Rob was a Klan-friendly cartoonist. Because his attacks on racism were often too subtle for a bumper-sticker mentality, he could be misunderstood by very literal-minded readers unacquainted with the irony of political cartoons.
When Rob did a cartoon about the #Oscar So White controversy at the Academy Awards, you would’ve thought he shouted the “n-word” in church or something.
People forget how merciless Rob was on Bill Clinton during his two terms. He was even harder on George W. Bush because there was more material to work with. While Rob genuinely admired Barack Obama, he didn’t spare the 44th president full-fledged mocking when he deserved it.
Still, the cartoons that consistently generated the most hate mail usually involved the pope, pedophile priests or something unflattering about religion. Besides being accused of being anti-clerical, Rob’s patriotism has been called into question. Equating Hiroshima with terrorism in one cartoon did not make him popular with veterans or assorted patriots.
The amazing thing about these cartoons is that all of them were defended by Rob’s editors at the time, no matter how much anger was directed the PG’s way. None of the cartoons was “ha-ha” funny, but all were provocative and appropriate for the moment.
Rob’s most recent cartoons were spiked because they were considered “mean” or “not funny.” Such things are highly subjective, but the cartoons were clearly in the award-winning tradition of his previous work.
That’s why the Rob Rogers of 1998 would be astonished by the outpouring of love and support he’s received from the public in 2018. His work is acclaimed and celebrated now far beyond the circulation of the PG. “I’m surprised by all the emails I’m getting from people who are discovering me because I lost my job,” he told me over coffee recently. He’s become a constantly trending topic on social media. Since his firing, he has dozens of options to weigh while continuing his editorial cartoons for syndication. “Don’t cry for Rob Rogers,” he said, savoring an opportunity to cite “Evita.” “Cry for the readers. Cry for Pittsburgh. I’ll be fine.”
As for our mutual defense pact, Rob has been gracious enough not to bring it up. It’s a relief to not have to be held to account whenever his name flashes on my Caller ID.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.