American popular culture desperately needs a Truth and Reconciliation Commission similar to the one South Africa convened shortly after the fall of Apartheid.
Recent controversies involving media and entertainment personalities have pushed big stories like the dramatically revised death toll from last year’s killer storm in Puerto Rico off the public’s radar.
These days we’re obsessed with Roseanne Barr’s racist tweets, comedian Samantha Bee’s use of a vulgar term to refer to Ivanka Trump and the controversy over whether Bill Clinton ought to personally apologize to Monica Lewinsky for the the sexual dalliance that ruined her life and morally compromised his presidency.
All of these are interesting topics worthy of discussion, but too much of it occupies valuable media bandwidth that could be devoted to issues that would (probably) guarantee that President Trump served less than a full term in office if the American people knew about them.
This is where an American version of South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission could come in and relieve some of the pressure on the mainstream media to cover popular culture’s latest controversies.
For instance, remember the fake controversy over Michelle Wolf’s White House Correspondents Dinner performance in which she was accused of making fun of White House spokeswoman Sarah Huckabee Sanders’ looks? Remember the hypocritical pearl-clutching by both administration officials and the Washington media during a week in which Ms. Wolf was pilloried for being an irreverent comedian who had the audacity to show up and disrupt their self-important ritual of flattering those in power?
Once ordinary people got a look at the actual footage of Ms. Wolf doing her thing, it was obvious that it was an artificial controversy cooked up by censorious liberals on “Morning Joe” and perpetuated by conservatives desperate to score points in the Culture Wars.
Had l’affaire Wolf gone straight to The People’s Court of Pop Cultural Controversy (PCPCC), it could have been wrapped up in a half-hour including two commercial breaks. Taking one’s case directly to the court of public opinion that values pragmatism over posturing makes far more sense.
Right now, pundits at Fox News and CNN are falling over themselves rushing to condemn MSNBC’s Joy Reid for blog posts from a decade ago laying bare the liberal commentator’s history of homophobia. Ms. Reid didn’t help her case by suggesting that many of the most embarrassing blog posts were created by trolls and hackers — an obvious lie on her part.
Still, Ms. Reid would have benefited mightily from a session before the PCPCC in which she would have probably been more inclined to provide straightforward testimony about having once been a homophobe, worked her way through it and is now a committed ally of the LGBTI community who is ashamed of her former opinions. An apology with context like that would go a long way. That’s what truth and reconciliation is all about.
I would even hold out hope for famous Ambien abuser and racist-conspiracy theorist Roseanne Barr under a system like that. Imagine if Ms. Barr who caused the cancellation of her successfully rebooted ABC show had gone to the PCPCC to humbly admit what is obvious to everyone — she’s imbibed deeply from very racist and conspiratorial waters for a long time.
Perhaps Ms. Barr could make an argument that mental illness is a mitigating factor, but it would provide a dignified way for her to own up to big mistakes, especially if she agreed to give up tweeting and acting like a moron in public.
If Ms. Barr also deeply and sincerely apologized to three black women she attacked in tweets last week — Valerie Jarrett, Michelle Obama and Whoopi Goldberg, I could see the PCPCC looking kindly upon her petition to be allowed within 100 miles of a network sound stage again.
Testimony from her co-workers and the production company about the value of the show as a much-needed vehicle for exploring white working-class alienation would be invaluable.
Ms. Barr doesn’t write the show, but a highly dedicated team of liberal and progressive writers, do. They’ve actually been truer to the working-class legacy of “Roseanne” than its titular star.
So, instead of scheming to bring the show back without its central character, “Roseanne” could be rebooted with Ms. Barr onboard after a year’s timeout in which she seeks therapy for her personality disorders and successfully proves she’s capable of resisting the lure of social media. There should be zero tolerance for her conspiracy theories and her casual racism.
Conservatives tempted to whine about “muzzling” Roseanne Barr under such onerous conditions should be reminded that NFL players operate under similar restrictions — they take a knee during the national anthem, they lose their jobs and their teams are fined millions.
Taking these cultural brouhahas to the PCPCC restores a much-needed element of proportionality. There’s no reason to cancel an entire series because of one cast member’s racism or past misdeeds. Take it to the People’s Court of Pop Cultural Controversy, instead.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.