Her medium may be photography, but artist Deana Lawson is first and foremost a poet of the black body. Her one-woman show at the Carnegie Museum of Art depicts black women and men settling into unremarkable domestic spaces throughout the African diaspora from Soweto to New York and North Carolina.

The images are staged, as are some of the objects that fill the familiar environments in which her subjects are situated. Ms. Lawson, who is African-American, is not interested in documenting any particular reality as much as mining universal truths just beneath the surface of things.

In “Woman with Child” (2017), a woman sits uncomfortably on a sofa cradling a crying baby while meeting the photographer’s eye as she’s given instructions on what to do next. Whatever one’s initial assumptions, they are immediately dashed upon learning the baby is not her child. The woman’s actual child is the toddler in the far left foreground. The baby in the woman’s arms is not hers and belongs to someone who lent it to the photographer for the shoot.

In “Barbara and Mother” (2017), a mother and daughter pose together in print dresses surrounded by the bric-a-brac of working-class life, including a box fan and a plastic-covered lampshade that practically every African-American born before 1980 will recognize. The mother mischievously reveals the prosthetic left leg under her dress while her daughter leans in as if to whisper something in her ear.

Advertise with us

Arguably, the most endearing photograph in the show is “Seagulls in Kitchen” (2017) featuring a couple standing midway between a refrigerator and a microwave oven. The scantily clad woman is a head shorter than the shirtless man embracing her from behind. His tan camouflage pants are a stark contrast to the dark stockings that cover her very small feet and legs.

Positioned behind the couple’s left shoulders are two plastic seagulls pinned to the wall by the artist. Seagulls appear to be Ms. Lawson’s personal spirit animals and can be counted on to show up in other photos in some form, like in the pattern on the bedspread in “Brother and Sister Soweto” (2017).

Because Ms. Lawson’s modus operandi is to pose her subjects and manipulate the environment they appear in to get at higher truths, her motives are immediately suspect to those who feel her real intention is to profit from pathological stereotypes about the black community.

None of the photos in this CMOA exhibit feels “uplifting” in the conventional sense, even though the dignified essence of life radiates from all of her subjects. This has inadvertently created a tricky set of politics for some viewers who prefer less grime mixed with truth.

Consider “Nation” (2018, shown above). Two gang members sit on a sofa, one gesturing at the viewer and the other chomping down on a device keeping his mouth open. Even those who are uncomfortable about some of the images don’t want to appear to be philistines even as they recoil from them.

Advertise with us

“Uncle Mack” (2017), the image of a middle-aged, potbellied black man posing with a shotgun, is the image visitors see as they walk past the Forum 80 gallery on the way to the Carnegie Museum of Natural History down the hall. One friend with a fairly sophisticated taste in art expressed concern that because of where it is physically positioned, a black man with a shotgun is the image that little kids will see as they’re skipping by. My friend, who is black, would feel a lot more comfortable if the show was tucked away in a less prominent gallery.

The show has prompted discussion on social media and questions about whether the gritty representation of people who haven’t been ritually airbrushed for the white gaze advances the longterm interest of black people. At least online, many black folks have expressed discomfort with the exhibit.

But Deana Lawson does not buy into the myths of our market-driven culture about what constitutes offensive imagery, especially when it comes to black people. She’s all about excavating inner poetry and beauty.

Consequently, the beauty Ms. Lawson’s photographs uncover is often disquieting and can easily be mistaken for its opposite. Deana Lawson is not the one to run to for idealized representations of anything, but she clearly understands how to tease out what is playfully ephemeral in her subjects during the long march toward representing the transcendent. This makes her one of the most exciting young artists on the scene today. With ambitions this grand, she’s bound to always be misunderstood.

Deana Lawson will be in conversation with curator Dan Leers, poet Rickey Laurentiis, Africana Studies professor Christel Temple and myself from 6 to 7:30 p.m. Friday at Forum 80 at the Carnegie Museum of Art. Admission is free for this conversation and gallery walk. Come with an open mind and lots of questions.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.