Wednesday was a strange day in politics, even by the standards of this very strange presidency. The cause of gun reform found itself an unlikely champion — for a few minutes at least.
Flanked by members of both parties at an afternoon roundtable at the White House, President Donald Trump conducted a discussion about the easy availability of assault weapons.
At one point, Vice President Mike Pence made a pitch for what are called “red flag” laws — a route for family members or the police to petition a court to temporarily remove guns from those who would be a danger either to themselves or the public.
Mr. Pence argued that this was an approach to the gun access and due process that would respect the absolutism of the Second Amendment and the imperative to keep guns out of the wrong hands when his boss interrupted him.
“Take the guns first,” the president said. “Go through due process second. I like taking the guns early.” It was a stunning declaration coming from a man elected with the help of $30 million from the National Rifle Association.
Mr. Trump expressed frustration that the 19-year-old killer of 17 students and faculty at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School was able to purchase high-powered guns legally simply because he wasn’t in the criminal justice system despite dozens of visits to his home by police over the years.
Looking around the room, Mr. Trump threw out the most heretical line with a practiced casualness: “I think they [the cops] should have taken [the guns] away, whether they had the right or not.”
Mr. Trump’s statement contradicted decades of NRA and gun industry orthodoxy. Though his predecessor was careful never to appear to advocate for gun confiscation, Mr. Trump echoed the gun lobby caricature of President Obama’s intentions. What Mr. Trump was advocating was an unconstitutional gun grab. Everyone realized it — except the president.
Democrats sitting at that table were stunned, but the Republicans looked genuinely alarmed as the president “went rogue” on an issue the NRA had not given their party any latitude to roam.
Shortly after that, Mr. Trump engaged in his version of the Socratic Method with Pennsylvania Sen. Pat Toomey, who is better than most of his Republican colleagues as far as gun-reform advocates are concerned, but is usually a reliable vote for the status quo despite being downgraded from an “A” to a “C” rating by the NRA.
Mr. Toomey and West Virginia Sen. Joe Manchin, a conservative Democrat, introduced legislation in response to the 2012 Sandy Hook massacre that came close to passage, but stalled because expanded background checks at gun shows and the internet is too radical for the gun industry.
When Mr. Trump asked if the Toomey-Manchin bill addressed his biggest concern — raising the age that a person could purchase a rifle from 18 to 21 — Mr. Toomey told him that it didn’t.
“You know why? Because you’re afraid of the NRA,” Mr. Trump said, putting Mr. Toomey on the defensive. The senator made a spirited argument for the right of 18-, 19- and 20-year-olds to buy the guns that have caused so much havoc because the overwhelming majority of the people who buy them don’t pose a threat to anyone.
“They are law-abiding citizens,” Mr. Toomey said. “They have that [rifle] because they want to use it for hunting or target shooting, and to deny them their Second Amendment right is not going to make anyone safer,” he said. It was the kind of defense that could get Mr. Toomey’s “A” rating with the NRA restored in no time.
Meanwhile, Mr. Trump bounced questions around the room like a cat playing with an unraveling ball of yarn. He told them that it was time to find a solution to the gun problem.
When Sen. Chris Murphy, a Connecticut Democrat, suggested that he was underestimating the power of the NRA to thwart a 60-vote supermajority, Mr. Trump figuratively beat his chest like Tarzan: “[The NRA] has great power over you people, they have less power over me,” he said.
“Some of you people are petrified by the NRA. You can’t be petrified,” Mr. Trump said. Earlier in the week, Mr. Trump announced he was so brave he would have rushed into the Florida school unarmed to rescue the people, so he was on a toxic masculine roll. It was ridiculous. But it was also briefly encouraging.
Was this the answer to the “thoughts and prayers” the nation had been waiting for after every mass shooting? Within hours, the NRA weighed in and flattered the president for putting on a good show, but insisted nothing of substance came out of the meeting. It continues to oppose raising the age limit for AR-15 purchases.
Despite the president’s momentary lapse into sanity for reasons of conscience or cynicism, the status quo will hold until the next election intervenes — or not.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.