Last week, Democrat Patty Schachtner won a special election in Wisconsin she wasn’t supposed to win. Ms. Schachtner beat Adam Jarchow, a Republican, for the Senate District 10 seat in a rural strip of that state that Donald Trump won by 17 points in 2016.
Ms. Schachtner, the medical examiner for St. Croix County, beat her heavily favored Republican opponent by 11 points for a seat that in the pre-Trump era would have gone uncontested.
Alas, the mood of the electorate — especially among Democrats — has shifted. In an era when Doug Jones, a pro-choice Democrat who helped prosecute Klansmen, can beat a notorious culture warrior like Roy Moore in blood-red Alabama, there’s a political reckoning afoot in America and it is painted blue.
Democrats are “bringing the pain” in a lot of districts holding special elections. Republican retirements and resignations in once solidly red seats are up. Civic-minded Democrats who don’t buy into the argument that heavily gerrymandered districts are lost causes are stepping forward.
That’s why former Rep. Tim Murphy’s seat in Pennsylvania’s 18th congressional district is suddenly in play when it would have been the easiest of strolls for any announced Republican in the pre-Trump era.
Mr. Murphy, you’ll recall, is the very married, very pro-life Republican who encouraged his mistress to have an abortion the second he thought another round of diapers were in his future.
For demonstrating hypocrisy verging on black comedy, Mr. Murphy was forced to step down, paving the way for a House special election on March 13.
Rick Saccone, another culture warrior from the 39th district of the Pa. House of Representative, had filed papers to challenge Sen. Bob Casey Jr., a moderate Democrat, but thought better of it when Mr. Murphy’s seat opened unexpectedly. Under the old rules, Mr. Murphy’s seat was so leveraged in favor of Republicans that a Democratic challenge was considered nothing more than a civic courtesy. That was before the blue rage began to build.
Mr. Saccone, a former civilian employee of the U.S. Army during the Iraq War and a big fan of torture that goes by the name “enhanced interrogation,” suddenly has a fight on his hands thanks to Conor Lamb, a former Marine and the scion of a Democratic political dynasty with deep roots in Western Pennsylvania.
Mr. Lamb already leads Mr. Saccone in fundraising and has closed the Republican advantage in the district to low single digits. Mr. Trump is so concerned about being dealt another humiliating loss in a district he once won that he has vowed to return to the area soon to “fill a stadium” for Mr. Saccone.
Mr. Saccone is going to need more than a stadium full of Trump supporters cheering road-tested laugh lines to win the district. He’s going to need actual voter enthusiasm — something the notoriously charisma-free politician lacks. Meanwhile, the young and energetic Mr. Lamb has plenty of campaign enthusiasm to spare with volunteers and money pouring in from everywhere.
Because Mr. Saccone’s battle cry is that he “was Trump before Trump was Trump” is a non-starter for most politicians in 2018, it will be interesting to see if he suddenly realizes that it may be to his advantage to at least pretend to be an independent thinker and not a Trump rubber stamp to be politically viable.
While Mr. Saccone contemplates Conor Lamb and other Democrats surfing a big blue wave into seats gerrymandered into tortured parodies of democracy, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled on Monday that the state’s entire congressional map is unconstitutional and has to be redrawn by Feb. 9.
Republicans are sure to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court to preserve an unfair advantage not sustained by the number of votes or party registration it can generate, but ordinary Pennsylvanians won’t be fooled. All voters, regardless of party, are finally becoming aware of the systemic assault on any fair electoral outcome represented by gerrymandered districts.
I originally planned to spend an entire column bemoaning the fact that Rick Saccone’s side gig as an apologist and “interrogation consultant” for the excesses that took place at Abu Ghraib has rendered him wholly unsuited for any office in our great commonwealth, but the Jan. 19 report in The Intercept speaks for itself. Go read it.
As Mr. Saccone has often stated, he arrived at Abu Ghraib long after the pictures of sadistic treatment of prisoners by U.S. military guards shut down abuse at the prison. But he has consistently argued that waterboarding, the simulated drowning of prisoners, shouldn’t be classified as torture at all.
While a candidate’s attitude toward waterboarding isn’t the primary reason voters will be headed to the polls on March 13, I absolutely love the symbolism of a big blue wave rolling in to drown Mr. Saccone’s hopes and dreams for higher office. It couldn’t happen to a more self-righteous guy.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.