For years I’ve been a faithful customer of D’s Six Pax and Dogz in Regent Square. As a three-decade resident of nearby Swisshelm Park, I have made D’s my de facto neighborhood bar.
I’m not a beer connoisseur, but I’m always able to find something interesting and palatable among the hundreds of beer bottles and cans on display in its refrigerated walk-in beer vault. Besides being well-lit, D’s can accommodate vegetarians and has a friendly staff that earns its tips.
It’s the place I consistently take out-of-town visitors. Though the customers are overwhelmingly white because of the neighborhood demographics, I’m rarely the only black guy there.
Not once have I ever felt unwelcome, intimidated, condescended to, overcharged, victimized or hurried along to make room for someone to grab my table. D’s has always struck me as a more-than-respectable watering hole for people of all persuasions. That’s why I have no intention of boycotting it, despite the recent controversy swirling around Dino DeFlavio, the man who runs the restaurant.
On Oct. 28, Mr. DeFlavio attended a Halloween party wearing a curly black wig, shades, a colorful print shirt and brown makeup. Mr. DeFlavio insists it was a tribute to his favorite artist — 1970s soul and jazz-pop crooner Gino Vannelli — and not a racially tinged parody of Rick “Super Freak” James, as some suspect.
As someone who came of age in the 1970s, I have to confess I listened to more than my fair share of Gino Vannelli records. On “Crazy Life,” his 1973 debut, he appeared on the cover sporting an exceptionally dark tan, a massive afro, a colorful scarf and a flower print shirt.
Given the trajectory of his music through that decade, Mr. Vannelli was probably attempting a pre-Michael Jackson style blurring of racial categories. He was considered “down” enough to be invited to perform on “Soul Train” shortly after Herb Alpert signed him to A&M Records, but his skin color got noticeably lighter the more successful he became in the pop music world.
Though an aesthetic misstep, that 1973 cover didn’t disqualify him from snapping up the opening slot for Stevie Wonder’s triumphant 1974 world tour. The Italian-Canadian from Montreal clearly loved black music and black people, if the racial makeup of his band and background singers were any indication.
Still, using that album cover as the basis for a Halloween costume 44 years later is problematic at best. Most people inclined to be offended by what appears to be crude blackface and not pop-star homage weren’t alive when it came out and aren’t likely to make the connection.
They don’t recall black folks giving Mr. Vannelli the benefit of the doubt for coming perilously close to being a ’70s version of Al Jolson. It was also an era in which no one would have cared if blacks complained, anyway. That is not the case today.
I don’t know Dino DeFlavio and don’t recall ever having met him at D’s (I must say that he doesn’t look familiar from the blackface shot circulating on Facebook). I don’t know if I totally believe him, but I want to believe him. His excuse for wearing what looks like blackface is so wild and improbable that it strikes me as extremely plausible in a world where people do stupid and counterintuitive things all the time. Who could come up with Gino Vannelli alibi if it weren’t true on some level?
I respect my friends and acquaintances who believe a line has been crossed and that Mr. DeFlavio has to have known better. Many of these friends — some whom have even eaten at D’s with me — say they won’t go back. I haven’t tried to talk them out of a personal and principled decision to boycott D’s. I’ve simply reached a different conclusion based on my experience there and the kind of business I believe it is.
Yes, Mr. DeFlavio should’ve known better given all of the post-Halloween stories in the news every year about blackface stunts by whites that generate public outrage, whether they were meant as racial insults or not.
“The Daily Show with Trevor Noah” even aired a Halloween public service announcement this year warning white people, especially the clueless ones, to stay away from the burnt cork. The whole minstrel thing has never been a good look for white folks indifferent to how it has been used to taunt and oppress black people.
With the recent tension in Regent Square generated by an anonymously hung noose on a tree near a black couple’s home (see a letter to the editor today), anything that could be interpreted as blackface burlesque was going to be a disaster once it migrated to social media.
When Dino DeFlavio was applying that dark makeup in the mirror and singing along to Gino Vannelli’s biggest hit “I Just Wanna Stop,” he should’ve followed that 1970s icon’s sage advice and just stopped.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.