While watching the season finale of “Game of Thrones,” I had to join all those who have noticed how the show — with all of its conflict, betrayal and manipulation in high places — bears resemblance to our current political drama.
The parallels are everywhere, which may simply be a function of the human condition. It wouldn’t be remarkably different whether one lives in fictional Westeros or Washington, D.C.
But “Game of Thrones” is just as interesting for the way in which it deviates from our political moment. Before I proceed, let this be a spoiler alert — details about the final episode follow.
The episode called “The Dragon and the Wolf” abounds with fine speeches about duty, honor and the value of telling the truth, no matter the cost. Airing as it did on a weekend in which President Donald Trump pardoned a racist sheriff who defied judges who attempted to curb his arbitrary exercise of power, Jon Snow’s honesty at a pivot point in the episode created a remarkable contrast to the far more cynical machinations in real-life Washington.
Because the world of ordinary, but warring humans is about to be plunged into frozen darkness by an advancing army of undead from the north known as White Walkers, Jon Snow seeks to form an alliance with a spiteful and suspicious queen who demands his allegiance as a condition for aiding his war effort.
All he has to do is say he will be “loyal,” whether he truly means it or not and he would have another powerful army at his disposal. Instead of giving Queen Cersei Lannister what she wants, Jon Snow goes on to make a speech that sounds like a refutation of the Trump era’s lies and equivocations. His allies are furious because his honesty has doomed them to fight an existential threat with less resources.
Jon Snow: “I am true to my word, or I try to be. That is why I cannot give you what you ask. I cannot serve two queens. I’ve already pledged myself to Queen Daenerys of House Targaryen.”
Tyrion Lannister: “Have you ever considered learning how to lie every now and then, just a bit?”
Jon: “I’m not going to swear an oath I can’t uphold. Talk about my father if you want. Tell me that’s the attitude that got him killed. But when enough people make false promises, words stop meaning anything. Then there are no more answers — only better and better lies, and lies won’t help us in this fight.”
Tyrion: “The immediate problem is that we’re [screwed].”
It is a thrilling debate by two men who see the same danger and want desperately to avert it, but one of them refuses to abandon his integrity and swear a false allegiance even for humanity’s sake.
There was plenty of second-guessing by viewers, split between those who consider Jon Snow’s nobility an admirable trait and those who consider it a tactical liability.
A bit of wistfulness is unavoidable watching the scene because there are so few people in our contemporary politics who ever mean what they say, so when we see it in its purest form on a TV drama, there’s something about it that almost feels pathological.
Think of the silence of most GOP leaders in the wake of the Joe Arpaio pardon, the president’s illogical and arbitrary ban on transgender recruits in the military and Mr. Trump’s decision to resume sales of heavy weapons to domestic police forces for use against civilians across the country. All of these things are stupid and shortsighted, but it takes courage to say it.
With the exception of pundits and politicians near the end of their terms or out of office, very few people who aren’t ordinary citizens feel compelled to speak truth to power. We are witness to the moral abdication of an entire elected political class.
Sadly, elected Democrats don’t have a strong bench of political leaders whose moral convictions can be heard above the partisan rabble, either. At best, to use a parallel from “Game of Thrones,” Democrats have Sen. Bernie Sanders, who is kind of like Lady Olenna Tyrell, an elderly, but politically savvy spitfire who falls fatally short of her ultimate goal after scoring big victories early on.
Some parallels are obvious: Little Finger is the Steve Bannon-like figure and instigator of the “War of the Five Kings” who finally gets outmaneuvered. While the temptation to compare Mr. Trump to the double-crossing and manipulative Cersei is understandable, she’s too competent a head of state for the comparison to stick. Though cruel and vindictive, she actually knows how to wield the levers of government. If anything, Mr. Trump is more like the nihilistic King Aerys Targaryen —”The Mad King” — overthrown in a civil war by those closest to him decades earlier.
Like the characters on “Game of Thrones,” our winter of discontent is just beginning.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.