Last week may have been President Donald Trump’s worst week in office — and that followed a week in which he threatened North Korea with nuclear annihilation.
It was a week in which Mr. Trump somehow managed to come up with the mildest words to denounce neo-Nazis only to repudiate his own words the following day during a contentious exchange with reporters in which he once again morally equated hatemongers with those who protested against them.
“Sad to see the history and culture of our great country being ripped apart with the removal of our beautiful statues and monuments,” Mr. Trump tweeted later.
Repeating the slippery slope argument from his earlier tantrum, Mr. Trump warned that removing statues and monuments celebrating Stonewall Jackson and Robert E. Lee would lead inevitably to the removal of George Washington and Thomas Jefferson from public spaces simply because they were slave owners.
When one has as poor a grasp on history as our president does, it’s easy to conflate the accomplishments of those who were architects of our problematic democracy with those who took up arms against it in a civil war that claimed 600,000 lives.
Mr. Trump approaches the controversy as if it is really a massive plot by lefty-iconoclasts working to remove all white men from public spaces. It is a paranoid view of the opposition to Confederate monuments ginned up in the chat rooms of the alt-right and regurgitated by Breitbart and Fox News. Repeating it gave succor to the white nationalist mob who gathered in Charlottesville two weekends ago.
Read More
Still, Mr. Trump’s opportunistic turn to Confederate idolatry as his approval rating tanks has provided an opportunity to discuss what is worthy of occupying our public spaces and what might be more appropriately placed in museums, galleries or libraries where context can transmit a fuller story.
When it comes to monuments and statues, I’m convinced that our most vexing controversies could be solved with the application of a little empathy, common sense, historical context and an appreciation of how human dignity works.
For instance, slave shackles on display behind glass in a museum have a deeper and longer connection to American history than any monument to Robert E. Lee, but it would be appalling to see shackles displayed at a bus stop in Oakland. That’s simply not the most appropriate place to tell the story of American slavery. It would be an affront to all citizens, but especially black citizens.
“Colored only” and “white only” signs above water fountains and outside of rest rooms and restaurants were once ubiquitous, but no one would dream of letting them continue to dot the landscape just because they’re a part of our history. Balancing contemporary values of non-discrimination with an accurate understanding of our history is more important than feeding the endless nostalgia for a more oppressive time and place.
This logic also applies to the Stephen C. Foster statue in Oakland, an example of patronizing, but high-minded racism I first wrote about in 2010. Ostensibly meant to celebrate the talent of the Lawrenceville-born composer, the statue also includes as a sidekick in immortality, a subservient black character from one of Foster’s songs.
The statue is irredeemably embarrassing as an outdoor ambassador for 21st-century Pittsburgh, but a lot of folks think it is sacrilege to speak of moving it to inside the museum next door. They’re used to it being outside and resist conceding it is offensive simply because the original intent wasn’t racist. It is “accidentally” racist by today’s standards.
Meanwhile, we know there are folks who want to wallow in the familiar fumes and odors of the past when you could insult non-whites with impunity. They miss the smell of grandma’s apple pie and grandpa’s racism, but, so what?
This is not a country that typically builds monuments to adversaries, yet we lionize the Confederacy. There are no officially sanctioned Hitler statues, Joseph Stalin Parks or public schools named after Osama bin Laden or Saddam Hussein. Such things would be unimaginable. Yet the organized domestic terrorism of the Confederacy killed a lot more Americans than the Islamic State ever will.
So, why has America tolerated the existence of hundreds of monuments in public spaces dedicated to traitors who warred against this country? If Benedict Arnold isn’t considered “honorable,” why should Southern generals be celebrated?
If we’re honest, we’ll admit that Confederate statues were meant as giant middle fingers to the civil rights aspirations of black people whether erected after Reconstruction, during Jim Crow in the 1920s or during the civil rights struggle of the 1950s and ’60s.
That’s why Confederate flags and monuments should be in museums next to slave shackles, Stephen Foster statues and “whites only” signs. They’re relics of a time when America was less free and more gullible.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.