Like many Americans old enough to remember duck-and-cover drills in public school, I have been in denial about the utter insanity of the nuclear brinkmanship by President Donald Trump and North Korea’s Kim Jong Un this week.

I don’t remember having this vague and persistent sense of the possibility of mushroom clouds on the horizon since 1984, when President Ronald Reagan joked during a sound check for a radio address that America would begin bombing the Soviet Union in five minutes.

The Soviets didn’t think “Rocket Ronnie” was very funny and denounced his “monstrous statement.” Months later, the Pentagon confirmed that the Soviets had put military forces on high alert.

The 1983 TV drama “The Day After” captured the sense of paranoia that Americans felt at the height of the Cold War when the world’s two greatest superpowers appeared to be slouching toward an inevitable nuclear showdown.

Advertise with us

I remember the sense of impending doom being very palpable, especially in the mid-1980s when I lived in New York and daily life already felt like a post-apocalyptic drag. Reading Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons’ brilliant “Watchman” comic book series every month didn’t exactly quell my anxieties. Every corner of popular culture screamed that we were all doomed, though it wasn’t as intense as it must have been during the Cuban Missile Crisis two decades earlier.

No one thought that either we or the Soviets would intentionally launch missiles first. Such a war would guarantee the destruction of the other and its allies by a massive retaliatory strike. But the threat of Mutual Assured Destruction was little consolation. The assumption was that armageddon would probably be initiated by an accident or a strategic miscalculation.

Something as banal as a flock of geese or an unusual cloud formation interpreted as a pre-emptive strike by an inattentive general could make much of the planet uninhabitable for hundreds of years.

For the moment, two petulant antagonists are in a position to set humanity’s forward evolution back many thousands of years as well as cause the immediate deaths of hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people.

The fact that the war of words between Donald Trump and Kim Jong Un comes 72 years to the week that the United States dropped atomic bombs on two highly populated Japanese cities to end World War II isn’t lost on anyone who has ever heard of karma. Unlike any other country in the world, America crossed the threshold and killed civilians by the multiple thousands with the most fearsome weapon in any country’s arsenal.

Advertise with us

In an attempt to end the Korean conflict a decade after Japan’s unconditional surrender, President Dwight Eisenhower back-channeled a threat to use nukes on North Korea and its Chinese allies if they didn’t come to the negotiation table. Since America had demonstrated zero hesitation about using nukes in Asia, this threat led to a ceasefire, but not an end to the Korean War.

There’s no evidence that Mr. Trump thinks in terms of long-term strategic goals and consequences like his Cold War predecessors did.

“North Korea best not make any more threats to the United States,” Mr. Trump thundered earlier this week from his golfing retreat in Bedminster, N.J. “They will be met with fire and fury like the world has never seen.”

After hearing Mr. Trump’s threat, I’m sure I wasn’t the only one reminded of a recent episode of HBO’s “Game of Thrones” in which Daenerys Targaryen, the “mother of dragons,” vowed to abandon more conventional strategies in her war for the iron throne in favor of going nuclear with her dragons.

But for all of her impatience due to unforeseen military setbacks, even Daenerys Targaryen isn’t as bellicose as Mr. Trump, and she has actual dragons at her disposal. Mr. Trump has the largest nuclear arsenal in the world at his disposal, but it is clear that 72 years after Hiroshima, he doesn’t understand what deterrence means.

Advertise with us

North Korea doesn’t represent the existential threat to the international order that the White Walkers or even the formidable army of Lannisters do to Daenerys’ ambitions to rule the Seven Kingdoms.

For his part, Kim Jong Un is not Cerci Lannister. If anything, he’s more like Joe Pesci’s Tommy DeVito in “Goodfellas.” He’s a fearsome runt who routinely intimidates folks much bigger than himself, but is ultimately destined to get whacked the moment he crosses a previously invisible line.

So why does Mr. Trump talk of Kim Jong Un as if the leader of one of the poorest nations was a grave enough threat to risk the continued existence of much of Asia with a series of pre-emptive nuclear strikes?

Is going to war with North Korea worth the likely destruction of South Korea, parts of Japan, Guam and a sizable portion of the American forces at the Korean DMZ? Are we willing to risk a wider conflict with China, which would object to the use of nukes on its border? What’s the endgame for a conflict with North Korea?

Unlike the icy invasion of the White Walkers on “Game of Thrones,” is a nuclear winter in our future?

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.