As of the deadline for this column, six Republican senators held the fate of Obamacare in their hands. Moderate Republican Sens. Dean Heller of Nevada and Susan Collins of Maine expressed reservations about the Senate bill that goes by the perfectly Orwellian sobriquet “The Better Care Reconciliation Act.”

Conservative Sens. Rand Paul of Kentucky, Ted Cruz of Texas, Mike Lee of Utah and Ron Johnson of Wisconsin also have expressed reservations about the legislation. Mr. Lee and Mr. Cruz, in particular, are skeptical about it because it doesn’t go far enough in the direction of the House version to merit their support.

In the past, Mr. Paul has argued for the repeal of the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) because he doesn’t believe that government has a legitimate role to play as a provider of American health care. He’s more offended by the existence of Obamacare than excited by an opportunity to vote for “Trumpcare.”

Mr. Paul is a fierce believer in markets being allowed to find their own levels when it comes to health care. (It bears noting that he is a doctor who practiced opthalmology for years in Kentucky.) He considers “confiscating money from taxpayers” to be set aside for any old deadbeat with a medical emergency a bad thing and contrary to the principles of democracy.

Advertise with us

President Donald Trump may have characterized the first version of the bill sent over from the House as “mean,” but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t reflect his values. Once enacted on his watch, it will indict him, his administration and the entire Republican-controlled legislative branch.

I used to have enough faith in American democracy to say that something this crazy couldn’t happen, but I’ve been consistently wrong about these things for the last year. People in power are cynical. They know most Americans don’t vote and aren’t in the position to hold them responsible because they don’t care enough about the process to intervene when something crazy is about to happen.

On Monday, the Congressional Budget Office estimated that the Senate version of Trumpcare will result in 22 million fewer Americans having health coverage over the next decade. In a nation of informed citizens, that would have triggered coast-to-coast riots.

Critics have long argued that repealing Obamacare and replacing it with Trumpcare will effectively shred the social safety net Americans have taken for granted for decades. But Republicans say it is necessary to be cruel in the short term to be kind in the long run.

Aid to low- and middle-income people in the form of Medicaid will be cut back dramatically, making meaningful private health insurance unaffordable for most Americans. States that took advantage of Medicaid expansion will be up a creek.

Advertise with us

Insurance companies will be allowed to charge whatever they believe the market will bear for premiums purchased by people in late middle-age and up. Consequently, rates will skyrocket. They also can consider pre-existing conditions and discriminate based on age and health status. This is worse than what most Americans had before Obamacare, even though it will take a decade to play itself out in all of its awfulness.

Insurance policies can be stripped of any useful utility like covering pregnancies, birth control, addictions or mental health. If there’s an opioid epidemic, this bill doesn’t recognize it. Employers will no longer have to honor the mandates of the ACA when it comes to their workers. Maternity and paternity leave and all sorts of concessions to “nanny state overreach” will soon be undermined as that logic of individual responsibility is ruthlessly applied.

Those unlucky enough to show up at emergency rooms uninsured can still expect to receive the basic care they need to survive whatever trauma put them there in the first place, but they will get a bill for what it costs the hospital to extend their lives, even if it leads to bankruptcy.

Yes, that’s called the “dignity” of not having the state meddle in your health care affairs. If you can’t find an affordable policy on the individual market to address your needs, well, that’s on you. Why should your fellow American shoulder any of the cost for your lack of savvy?

Meanwhile, the billions “saved” by the Senate plan will be transferred to the wealthy in the form of tax cuts when Congress begins working on tax reform later this year. In total, Trumpcare is expected to reduce the federal deficits by $321 billion over the next decade.

Advertise with us

Of course, Trumpcare is opposed by every medical association, consumer and advocacy group imaginable. There is no association of doctors or medical professionals who approves of it. So how can it possibly pass? The answer is simple: Non-voting Americans don’t care about such things until they feel they personally have some skin in the game. Ultimately, what can be sicker than that?

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.