Maybe it’s because Woodland Hills High School has been in the news lately that I’ve been thinking a lot about my own time in high school in Philadelphia four decades ago.
I spent a year at a typical high school in West Philly before transferring to a school that specialized in the creative and performing arts. I left my neighborhood school because of an exceptionally bad grade I got in a subject I loved.
The problem was that the high school up the street had two art teachers — one acclaimed throughout the school district who taught only 11th- and 12th-graders and one very high-strung teacher who taught 10th grade. You had to pass Mrs. J’s class to get to Mr. K’s.
Back then, the day the final report card came out generated pure catharsis in the halls. Hardened kids who spent much of the year being class clowns or bullies bawled unashamedly because they had flunked enough classes to be held back a year.
My eyes teared up, too, but not because I failed the 10th grade — I didn’t. I was shaken because I had one bad grade on my report card, but it was in a subject I cared about more than any other. I was staring at an “F” in art.
I was both shocked and not shocked. The art teacher, a very dignified woman of very thin frame who carried herself like a ballerina, clearly disliked me — a sentiment I was more than happy to return.
Mrs. J was from the Brahmin class in the black community. Fair-skinned with eyes either blue or green (I don’t recall which), she could’ve easily passed for white if she had wanted, but she let her hair kink enough to give away the game — she was one of us.
Racial solidarity aside, she seemed to hate me from day one. All year, Mrs. J and I battled in her class. I boycotted the daily assignments and she scrupulously ignored me. While my classmates did still-life drawings, I drew superheroes and read comic books. I never tried to disrupt her class, but I barely acknowledged her authority.
My disrespect cost me. When she handed out applications for the Pennsylvania Governor’s School for the Arts, she made a point of skipping over me.
One day, she asked me to stop whispering to a student she happened to adore. I responded by saying something cruel — something I can’t bring myself to remember. She exploded and knocked a chair out of the way as she rushed toward me. I stood my ground — terrified. She screamed in my face, raining down spittle and tears. I was seething and contemptuous of this very tall woman looming over me. She smelled great, though. Still, I wondered if she was mad enough to put her hands on me and what I would do if she did.
I quickly gathered my books and went to the library, where I hid out for the rest of the year. I’d occasionally go back to art class, where I sulked and she avoided looking at me. None of my friends had a similar experience.
So, my final grade was well-earned, but I was enough of a solipsist to think it was unfair. It also meant I would have her for art class for another year — an unthinkable prospect.
All summer, I dreaded returning to my old school. Fortunately, my portfolio was good enough to qualify me for entrance to an alternative arts high school, so we were both spared a painful rematch.
As the years went by, I thought about our “feud.” At my new school, my problems with art teachers disappeared. It was great to be every teacher’s pet again. I even got into the Governor’s School.
While in college, I sent Mrs. J a brief note care of my first high school. I bragged, probably prematurely, about “making it” despite her skepticism. I never heard back from her, though a good friend of mine who was in touch with her said he mentioned me one day to get a reaction. She rolled her eyes and changed the subject.
I get it. Teachers aren’t obligated to like every student. I was an arrogant teenager who overcompensated for his insecurities with a big mouth. Still, I wanted to be liked by Mrs. J, but it simply wasn’t in the cards.
Today, I have no idea whether Mrs. J, who was already in her 40s in the mid-1970s, is still alive. A quick check of the internet turns up nothing. As someone who has taught and lectured for nearly two decades myself, I feel a lot more sympathy for her now than I used to.
If I ever bumped into Mrs. J, I’d smile sheepishly and say how sorry I was. Even if she rolled her eyes, I’d mean it.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.