I’m still reeling from Sunday night’s Oscars ceremony broadcast — and I didn’t even watch it. After the biggest on-stage snafu in Academy Award history, “Moonlight” — an often bleak coming-of-age film about a black man who discovers his homosexuality despite internal and community resistance — was named Best Picture.
Somehow the low-budget independent film beat heavily favored “La La Land,” a big-budget feel-good musical that unabashedly celebrates Hollywood ambition and escapism.
The victory of “Moonlight” over “La La Land” was especially surprising because of the way it won. Hollywood royalty Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway opened the envelope given to them and announced “La La Land” the winner, despite Mr. Beatty’s visible suspicion that something was amiss.
Fifty years ago, Mr. Beatty and Ms. Dunaway starred in Arthur Penn’s “Bonnie & Clyde,” a brilliant, starkly violent narrative about the notorious Dust Bowl couple that robbed banks and eluded lawmen until an associate betrayed them. “Bonnie & Clyde” was nominated for Oscars in most of the major categories including Best Picture, but lost to “In the Heat of the Night,” Norman Jewison’s Southern crime drama starring Sidney Poitier and Rod Steiger as the racial Odd Couple cops tasked with solving a murder.
That year “Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner” starring Mr. Poitier was also on the ballot, making it the most diverse Best Picture contest in Oscar history up until that point.
Mr. Beatty is used to being in symbolic contests over cinematic representation and probably expected to see “Moonlight” listed as the winner, given his own experience as an Oscar underdog. He was clearly startled to see “Emma Stone, ‘La La Land’ ” on the card before handing it to Ms. Dunaway, as they had earlier agreed, to do the honors.
In retrospect, it looks like Mr. Beatty wanted to do the “right thing” and slow everything down and wait for a second opinion before handing off the Oscar, but that was impossible. More than a billion people were waiting breathlessly.

In fact, everyone, including his co-presenter, Ms. Dunaway, assumed the hemming and hawing that has endeared Mr. Beatty to movie audiences for decades was evidence he was having a senior moment. “You’re impossible,” Ms. Dunaway said before taking the envelope and pronouncing “La La Land” the winner.
What happened next has been recounted millions of times in newspapers and across social media. Betting pools were stunned. Oscar-watching parties careened between jubilation for “Moonlight” and shock over the unprecedented nature of seeing announced winners already on stage ceding the Oscar to the real winners.
It took a few minutes of well-dressed bedlam to sort itself out as director Barry Jenkins, the producer and the cast of “Moonlight” were finally accorded their moment at the center of Hollywood’s reddest, hottest evening.
Conspiracy theories of all shapes will eventually attach themselves to a moment that was nothing more than the result of a careless handoff of the wrong envelope to two stars who could not comprehend the error while the eyes of the world were upon them.
Sure, it would’ve been great if Warren Beatty had had the presence of mind and confidence in his suspicions to tell the audience he believed he had been handed the wrong envelope. It would’ve added some awkwardness to the evening while the firm that oversees the process addressed his doubts — but Mr. Beatty would’ve been applauded for his vigilance, especially if a historic snafu had been avoided.
While watching that dramatic scene play itself out online Monday morning, I was reminded of how much the ending of the 2017 Academy Awards was emblematic of how strange the entire world of politics and entertainment has been for the last year.
In politics, the unlikely victory of the forces pushing for Britain’s exit from the European Union won last summer, despite the polls and the odds. Donald Trump’s victory over former first lady, senator and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton for the presidency of the United States still feels like a very elaborate prank played on our democracy.
From Beyonce’s Grammy loss to Adele for Album of the Year to the shocking finale of the Super Bowl that had the New England Patriots scoring an unprecedented 25 points over the Atlanta Falcons in the second half and winning in overtime, we can all think of something we’d love to see “done over” as quickly and efficiently as the victory of “Moonlight” over “La La Land” proved to be.
Imagine a redo of the Democratic presidential nomination. Imagine Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders going up against Donald Trump in the November general election instead of Hillary Clinton. Given his populist rhetoric, it isn’t likely that Mr. Sanders would’ve been outmaneuvered like Ms. Clinton was by Mr. Trump in appealing to the working-class white voters of Pennsylvania, Ohio, Michigan and Wisconsin.
Or, imagine a Clinton v. Trump scenario in which the electorate knew then what it knows now about the contours of a Trump presidency. The outcome would’ve been different without a doubt.
But there’s no point in imagining counterfactual scenarios. We have to deal with the things that are with as much integrity as we can muster. “Do overs” rarely happen in real life. That’s just “La La Land.” There won’t be any “Moonlight” over the Potomac anytime soon, either.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.