After watching the Atlanta Falcons blow a 25-point lead over the New England Patriots in one of the most thrilling NFL championship games in memory, it’s obvious why the ranks of those suffering from Tom Brady Derangement Syndrome will never be depleted.
I don’t exempt myself from this sad crew of haters. I really, really, really wanted the Falcons to wipe the floor with the Patriots at Super Bowl LI, and for three quarters, I was happy. There’s something about New England’s collective smugness and (admittedly) earned privilege that never fails to set my teeth on edge, so I tend to root against them.
It’s irrational, I know. There are 32 teams in the National Football League. I think it’s safe to say that millions of hardcore fans of the 31 teams that are not the New England Patriots have a passionate, um, “dislike” for Tom Brady, the game’s best quarterback.
Long after he leaves the game and is sitting in the U.S. Senate as a member of the Trump wing of the GOP, football fans will continue to have strong feelings about Tom Brady.
Euphemisms aside, the hatred many feel for Mr. Brady actually goes up a few more notches for Patriots coach Bill Belichick, a laconic, vaguely Luciferian figure widely credited as the most opportunistic tactician the game has ever produced. His reputation for bending the rules only enhances his appeal with those for whom morality is merely a question of whether the Patriots win or not.
Together, the QB and coach have won five Super Bowls and lost two. Their Faustian ingenuity combined with an almost supernatural focus on the mechanics of winning have turned the New England Patriots into the most dominant franchise of the modern era.
Sad to say that they eclipsed the Pittsburgh Steelers in that regard a long time ago, though someone told me once that the Steelers have the most passionate fan base of any NFL team by virtue of being everyone’s default team behind their home team. I don’t think its possible for the Patriots to be anyone’s second-favorite team, though it would be foolish for anyone inclined to gamble to bet against them on anything.
This year, Tom Brady Derangement Syndrome is particularly acute because of the proximity of presidential politics. Both Mr. Brady and Mr. Belichick were implicated as early supporters of Donald Trump long before he won the presidency in a Patriots-over-Falcons-like victory against Hillary Clinton last November.
Though I concede there is an undeniable silliness to conflating their superior prowess on the football field with Mr. Trump’s less-than-impressive presidency three weeks in, the temptation to do so was nearly irresistible.
These three men have a relationship that is as affectionate and mysterious as Mr. Trump’s relationship with Russian President Vladimir Putin (minus the blackmail elements widely suspected to grease the wheels of that weird bromance).
From Lady Gaga’s impressive half-time show to the commercials that made understated appeals for immigration and an embrace of a more diverse America, there were enough signifiers in Super Bowl LI to feel like a relitigation of the election.
It isn’t fair, but outside of New England, Mr. Brady and Mr. Belichick have became the personification of an immovable Old Order — symbols of a brutally efficient status quo that everyone instinctively hates. They are the establishment! As long as the two are still functioning at the height of their powers, it is impossible for the Patriots to ever be the underdogs in any scenario. The resentment that this generates on the part of fans of other franchises can’t be underestimated.
And let’s be honest: If Mr. Brady and Mr. Belichick were mysteriously assigned by divine fiat to any other NFL team tomorrow, the hatred those fans currently feel would be replaced with instantaneous love and lust for a dynasty. Football hatred is conditional. It always depends on who’s winning and who’s losing.
Meanwhile, facile analogies between the Patriots and Trump supporters versus the Falcons and anti-Trump voters break down when you realize that most New England fans are most likely liberal and probably dislike Mr. Trump disproportionately, compared to fans of other teams. After all, Massachusetts and most of New England went blue. Georgia went red big time.
Patriots tight end Marcellus Bennett made no secret of his distaste for Mr. Trump, even before he won the election. Mr. Bennett said months ago that if the Patriots won Super Bowl LI, his teammates would be making the trip to be honored by Mr. Trump without him. He reiterated that promise after Sunday’s game.
Don’t reach for your smelling salts just yet. Tom Brady opted out of making the trip to D.C. to be honored by President Barack Obama the last time the team won (he claimed he had a “family commitment,”) so there’s already a precedent for the presidential snub. Presumably, Mr. Bennett has the right to be just as principled as Mr. Brady was and stay home. He’s got his Super Bowl ring.
Speaking of Super Bowl rings, maybe Mr. Trump can use his clout with Mr. Putin to retrieve the Super Bowl ring that Patriots owner Bob Kraft alleges the Russian president nipped from him in 2005. But given Mr. Trump’s penchant for moral relativism when it comes to the U.S. and Russia, he just might give Mr. Belichick a sly look and chuckle at that ironic display of outrage.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.