This is not how I would have chosen to spend Inauguration Day 2017. A year ago, Democrats were fairly confident that Hillary Clinton would be the one reciting the oath of office today having narrowly dispatched either Gov. Jeb Bush or Gov. John Kasich.

Maybe if I had let my hopes and dreams get the better of me, I could’ve imagined Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders standing in Mrs. Clinton’s place after narrowly beating her for the Democratic nomination and running a textbook perfect campaign against the Republicans for the hearts and minds of working class voters. Bernie would’ve been my preference, but I would’ve (and did) vote for Hillary Clinton without reservation.

What I would never have imagined a year ago — and I know I’m not alone — is that Donald Trump would be taking the oath of office today. I could imagine a dark horse like Gov. Kasich squeaking by or even Marco Rubio pulling a historic upset, but the idea of a Trump victory was about as likely as that scene from “Independence Day” where aliens arrive and park their mile-long spacecraft above the White House before blasting it to smithereens.

Yet, here we are. Thanks to the unprecedented weakness of a once proud political party that allowed itself to be taken over by someone who barely acknowledges its principles, Donald Trump is now the 45th president of the United States.

Advertise with us

The Republicans were aided and abetted by Democrats — and I include myself in this company — who lacked the imagination to game out a worst-case scenario and adjust to it based on the unprecedented nature of practically everything that was happening in American politics on a daily basis.

Hillary Clinton ran a conventional — and ordinarily winnable — campaign against an opponent who was proud of how much he didn’t understand and what he didn’t know about conventional politics.

But Donald Trump would’ve been hard for any Democrat to beat this year even if he had faced Bill Clinton in his prime. President Trump was able to bypass logic and reach deep into the emotional brain of an electorate that was disgusted with the binary choices presented by conventional party candidacies.

President Barack Obama’s recent comments that he could’ve put together a winning coalition to beat Trump’s demagogic appeal would’ve made sense in 2008 and 2012, but 2016 was all about the overthrow of conventional persuasive rhetoric and the boiling over of pent-up working class anxieties.

Despite leaving the White House with a 60 percent approval rating, Mr. Obama’s appeal in a hypothetical contest against a skilled Know-Nothing like Donald Trump in 2016 would have been limited for the same reasons that Mrs. Clinton’s candidacy came up short — voters were in the mood to smash something.

Advertise with us

Republican primary voters used Donald Trump to decimate their most elite presidential candidates and devalue the very meaning of the term “conservative” in the process. They were joined in the general election by Democrats who revolted against their elites by voting for a candidate whose values are antithetical to their own, but who knows how to talk to them in a language they understand.

Mr. Obama’s assumption that the electorate will usually make a rational choice given an irrational option was tested in 2016 and came up short. American politics has entered a post-rational phase. How long it remains there will depend on how long it will take for Democrats to remember how to run, win and govern like Progressives and not corporate enablers incapable of generating excitement at the grassroots.

This was not an election that was lost because of Russian shenanigans or the dissemination of “fake news.” This election was lost because of razor-thin margins in a couple of states in the upper Midwest and mid-Atlantic that would’ve gone blue had Democrats bothered to vote in numbers as high as they did in 2008 and 2012.

Liberals didn’t come up empty in an ideological struggle with conservatives. Hillary Clinton won nearly 3 million votes more nationwide than Donald Trump, but came up short in the Electoral College because too many Democrats stayed home or voted for third-party candidates in Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin. Those Democrats couldn’t bring themselves to vote for Hillary Clinton.

If there is an upside to this, it is that Democrats now understand that we haven’t earned the right to assume everything will “work out” if we decide to do nothing. Long fought-for rights can be snatched away in a couple of election cycles. People are mobilizing across the country with a fervor unseen in many years. Locally, there’s The People’s Inauguration at Freedom Corner today at noon. Today and tomorrow, there will be marches in Washington and across the country. Americans of all stripes are starting to realize that American politics can be best understood as a contest — not a reality show.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.