How does that old cliche go? “There are some bells that just can’t be unrung”? This week, Pope Francis gave an interview to a Belgian Catholic newspaper that can’t be unheard, unseen or unsmelled, thanks to its blunt imagery.

“I believe that the media should be very clear, very transparent, and not fall prey — without offence, please — to the sickness of coprophilia, which is always wanting to communicate scandal, to communicate ugly things, even though they may be true,” Pope Francis said, according to the Vatican’s translation. “And since people have a tendency towards the sickness of coprophagia, it can do great harm.”

Because my vocabulary isn’t as expansive as it once was, I had to look up what the pope was referring to with “coprophilia” and “coprophagia.” Putting it as delicately as I can, Pope Francis accused the media of encouraging the public to develop an abnormal interest in, well, eating excrement. (Multilingual reporters have noted that the interview was conducted in his native Spanish, a language in which those terms are not always used literally but metaphorically, for expressing an interest in the morbid. That’s some comfort.)

As part of the wide-ranging interview, the pope was chiding the media for spreading disinformation. He said propagating fake stories to discredit anyone was “probably the greatest damage the media can do.” Perhaps peeved about being used as a prop in last month’s American presidential election, in which his entirely fictionalized “endorsement” of Donald Trump became a fake news staple, Pope Francis wasn’t in the mood to mince words or resort to papal niceties.

Advertise with us

What can one say to this vivid papal edict except: point taken.

Still, I was a little disappointed that Pope Francis didn’t make a clear distinction between the role of a free press covering “scandals” and “ugly things” as he calls them, “even though they may be true” — and the fake stories and assorted conspiracy theories that gullible people pick up from their social media streams.

There are incredible estimates that more than half of the stories on social media streams like Facebook leading up to the election should be considered “fake news.” These weren’t stories being pushed in the mainstream media. These were stories that had roots in the murky journalistic netherworld of Breitbart and World Net Daily and were picked up by popular conservative radio hosts and websites like the Drudge Report.

The example of Edgar Welch, the 28-year-old North Carolina man who strode into the Comet Ping Pong pizzeria in Washington, D.C., on Sunday, armed with an AR-15, is a case in point.

Mr. Welch, a married father of four, said he was seeking evidence of a child sex trafficking ring that he heard was run by Hillary Clinton and other top Democrats. He read on several websites that the D.C. pizzeria he emptied one round into was a well-known front for Satanic pedophilia.

Advertise with us

Mr. Welch told The New York Times that he got his information about the pizzeria from Alex Jones’ InfoWars.com, a site that President-elect Trump has spoken highly of despite the fact that it is Ground Zero for the so-called “9/11 Truther” movement and those who insist the Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre was a hoax perpetrated by the gun control movement.

Much has been made about the fact that Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn, Mr. Trump’s pick to be his national security adviser, and his 33-year-old son Michael G. Flynn subscribe to several outlandish conspiracy theories running rampant on social media. Both appear incapable of making distinctions between legitimate stories and fake stories.

The younger Flynn was recently fired from the Trump transition team after doubling down on the conspiracy theory about Comet Ping Pong, even after Edgar Welch was arrested for storming the pizzeria. This is the kind of dangerous ignorance that even the fact-averse Trump team can’t afford to be associated with so early in its tenure.

While I appreciate the pope’s bluntness, I think he missed an opportunity to call upon ordinary citizens to more closely scrutinize their sources of information.

According to a recent BuzzFeed survey, most adult Americans who come across fake news believe what they’re reading. This reflects both the gullibility of the American public, the failure of our educational system and the inability of the mainstream press to distinguish its product from garbage in a crowded media landscape.

Advertise with us

While I agree that it is a “sin” to propagate fake stories, I think Pope Francis would have been better off putting the onus on citizens to approach all news critically, but to be especially wary of fake stories.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.