One hundred and seventy-eight years ago, Georgetown University made $115,000 — a relatively cool $3.3 million in modern dollars — from the sale of 272 human beings. At the time, chattel slavery was a legally sanctioned institution in America. The right of white Americans to own Africans and their American-born descendants was as constitutionally protected a right as freedom of speech and the right to bear arms. The custom of buying and selling humans was considered no less sacred than the right and duty of the former colonies to rise up against foreign tyranny.
Georgetown University was a Jesuit school with students devoted to bringing body, mind and soul under discipleship to Christ. They were among the best and the brightest of the young republic. Like the White House and other tourist destinations in the District of Columbia, Georgetown University was carved out of unforgiving swampland by slave labor. Radical notions like the equality of all people before God regardless of race would have to wait for future priests, teachers and popes to mull over after sufficient treasure on Earth had been accumulated.
The black men and women who built the university had specific roles to fulfill — they were workhorses, regardless of their personal skill level. They lived, died and were bred like farm animals on Jesuit plantations in Maryland. The two Jesuit priests who sold their fellow humans to slave plantations in Louisiana to alleviate the university’s debt were Rev. Thomas F. Mulledy and Rev. William McSherry. Both had nice buildings named after them to commemorate their shrewd deal-making in the Martin Van Buren era.
Like good 19th-century bureaucrats, the scribes and accountants of Georgetown University kept careful records of the men and women they sold down the Mississippi to get itself out of debt. This is important. Nearly two centuries later, these records have come in handy as the now conscience-stricken university attempts to make amends for the moral obtuseness that once tolerated and profited from slavery. Though quasi-secular these days, Georgetown strives to reflect the best of the Catholic intellectual and spiritual tradition.
This week, Georgetown University announced that it would reach out to the African-American descendants of the 1838 sale as if they were the children of esteemed (re: deep-pocketed) alumni. The descendants of all those slaves who gave so much to Georgetown in the form of uncompensated sweat equity will be recruited as if they were “legacy” applicants and offered the same consideration as the children of those who have attended for generations.
“We will give descendants the same consideration we give members of the Georgetown community in the admissions process,” university president John DeGioia said in a statement to students and alumni.
Read More
Mr. DeGioia explained why one of the most exclusive schools in the country was expanding its definition of “legacy” and giving priority to potentially hundreds of black applicants who aren’t being recruited for one of the school’s prestigious athletic programs. The fact that the offer is also being extended to the descendants of those who weren’t sold in 1838, but contributed uncompensated labor that directly benefited the university puts even more names verified by extensive genealogical records and bills of sale into consideration.
Still, Georgetown is quick to allay concerns by alumni and incredulous outsiders that it is doling out free tuition to potential applicants. It isn’t extending guaranteed entry to Georgetown based on racial descent, either. What the university is offering is what it offers every other “legacy” applicant — a leg up in the process of entry. Despite built-in institutional advantages, every legacy applicant is expected to bring something to the table. Since most legacy students don’t view their good fortune as a high-toned form of affirmative action, they will resent the implication that their privilege isn’t earned.
It’s anyone’s guess about how many descendants of those shipped to Louisiana in 1838 would even be interested in attending Georgetown. It probably wouldn’t be an offer many would find particularly appealing even after the vetting process has cleared them for consideration, especially if they don’t have something to offer one of the school’s prestigious sports programs.
Still, the gesture will be appreciated as an honest acknowledgment that much of the school’s fortune was built on a crime of epic proportions. Georgetown is not alone, but it is the first among the nation’s most exclusive schools to do something as dramatic as this. It will be interesting to see what develops.
But even though there’s no guarantee of acceptance, even the elevation of a finite number of blacks to the status of legacy makes a lot of folks nervous and apoplectic. It comes across as a weak tea version of reparations — a slippery slope of white guilt manipulation that has no top and no bottom as far as they’re concerned. And what happens when Harvard, Brown, the University of Virginia and other schools with verifiable ties to slavery decide to engage in a “legacy race” with Georgetown? How would that change the complexion of so many of America’s top universities?
Back at Georgetown, the two buildings named in honor of the men who sold 272 men, women and children to alleviate the school’s debt have been renamed Isaac Hall in honor of a man who was sent to Louisiana in 1838 and Anne Marie Becraft Hall, in honor of a 19th-century teacher who established the first school for black girls in D.C. Educating America about its racist past one privileged institution at a time might turn out to be a far more meaningful gesture than making a new class of legacy applicants.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.