Last week in Altoona, Donald Trump’s tendency toward confirmation bias got the best of him. Looking out over a crowd that was overwhelmingly white and working-class, it was easy for him to hope that the mix of diehard supporters and curiosity seekers who had come to gawk were somehow demographically representative of the entire Pennsylvania electorate.
They weren’t, of course, but minor facts like that don’t matter to audiences predisposed to roll with the “mythic” facts and figurative language of the Trump campaign. The crowd was more than willing to accept Mr. Trump’s premise that Pennsylvania is a state where his lead over Hillary Clinton is not debatable.
The unskewed, literal truth is that Mr. Trump is running behind Ms. Clinton in Pennsylvania and in every other battleground state. This kind of unvarnished, un-Trumpian truth is, of course, useless to a campaign trying to maintain its morale along with the illusion it can win. This is why Mr. Trump is constantly forced to reach for a deeper, more emotional truth that can ever be accounted for by mere pollsters. By conjuring a set of circumstances where he isn’t a loser, he has to redraw the map.
Everyone remembers the quip by James Carville, the political brains behind the Bill Clinton campaign of 1992, that Pennsylvania is “Philadelphia and Pittsburgh with Alabama in between.” Mr. Trump takes it several steps further by insisting that Pennsylvania is Alabama, period. This bit of sleight of hand comes in handy if you’re a desperate candidate attempting to generate doubt about the legitimacy of Ms. Clinton’s likely victory in the state.
“We’re going to watch Pennsylvania,” he said. “Go down to certain areas and watch and study and make sure other people don’t come in and vote five times,” he said without naming the certain areas. “If you do that, we’re not going to lose. The only way we can lose, in my opinion — I really mean this, Pennsylvania — is if cheating goes on.”
Perhaps suspecting that the vigilante nature of what he was asking his supporters to do sounded too far-fetched a chore on Election Day, he said this: “We have to call up law enforcement, and we have to have the sheriffs and the police chiefs and everybody watching,” he said. “Because if we get cheated out of this election, if we get cheated out of a win in Pennsylvania, which is such a vital state, especially when I know what’s happening here, folks. I know. She can’t beat what’s happening here,” he said.
“The only way they can beat [me] in my opinion — and I mean this 100 percent — if in certain sections of the state, they cheat, OK? So I hope you people can sort of — not just vote on [Nov.] 8th — go around and look and watch other polling places and make sure that it’s 100 percent fine,” he said.
By now, we’re all used to Mr. Trump’s less-than-subtle racial dog whistles. The “certain areas” he’s speaking of are likely precincts in Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, not polling places in Fox Chapel, Paoli or Scranton. Donald Trump wants to inspire Pennsylvania voters to follow the example of those who ensured the “integrity” of the vote during the Jim Crow era by insisting on inspecting the papers and identification of fellow citizens to make sure all is in order.
How this is supposed to work in real life is never spelled out. No one sane can realistically envision a scenario in which election monitors from, say, Cranberry, roll up on a polling site in Homewood to observe who votes, while challenging those who look suspicious. What exactly is Donald Trump calling for here? Would he be comfortable with folks from the Hill District traveling to Mt. Lebanon to ensure the integrity of those votes? Someone is likely to get killed following his advice.
Much has been made on right-wing blogs and on Fox News about the lack of votes Mitt Romney got in black precincts in Philly during a race against a sitting black president in 2012, as if it were evidence of a grand conspiracy. These paranoids contend that only vote-rigging and electoral fraud could explain votes of 100 percent for Mr. Obama in parts of North and West Philly. But what about Mr. Romney’s utter failure to make a compelling case for inner-city folks to vote for him?
The people inclined to actually go to the polls in Philly are more likely to vote for the candidate they believe has their interests at heart. Besides, dictators who rig elections usually claim only 96 percent of the vote, not 100 percent. Vote stealers in Philly would know that, so why attract attention with blowouts of 100 percent unless they were real? Could it be that these blowouts, though they appear suspicious, are a genuine expression of popular sentiment in those communities?
Mitt Romney’s outreach to blacks may have been subpar, but Mr. Trump’s efforts are nonexistent in comparison. He may have prominent black surrogates like Ben Carson, Katrina Pierson and Omarosa working for him, but none are influential in the black community. If anything, they come off as a bit mercenary in their blind devotion to Donald Trump.
Mr. Trump is going to lose Pennsylvania and a whole lot of other states along the way. It will not be the fault of the New Black Panther Party, ACORN or people allegedly voting multiple times in North Philly or Wilkinsburg. It will be because Donald Trump is a spectacularly inept candidate who lacks the self-awareness to know how bad he truly is. He may be cynical, but he isn’t dumb. He knows that Pennsylvania isn’t Alabama, no matter how much he wishes it were so.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @TonyNormanPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.