It was 20 years ago last month that the late PG editor John G. Craig Jr. let me try my hand at writing a newspaper column. Because John was flinty, irascible and slow to praise, I had no idea whether he liked what I was doing with the column six months into its run. I was nervous. Just before it launched, John mischievously ran his finger across his throat to emphasize that my column could be “cut” at any moment if it turned out to be an embarrassment.
So when the first two or three columns ran and I got no reaction from him, I asked John in passing what he thought of what I was doing. “Oh, I haven’t gotten around to reading them yet,” he said with a straight face, looking more and more like a muscular Wallace Shawn every day. “I’ll let you know,” he said.
What a liar! John Craig read every word printed in the PG every day, of that I had no doubt. He would routinely stroll around the newsroom picking fights with reporters about details buried deep in their stories. He’d mock the word choice in headlines in the most obscure sections of the paper. He even kept track of what happened on the comics page, including the order of the strips. He prided himself on reading every letter to the editor before passing them on to be edited. If anyone had an opinion about what appeared in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, it was John G. Craig Jr., yet somehow my column escaped scrutiny. Whatever, dude!
Once it became obvious John wasn’t going to cut my column’s throat in the middle of the night, he finally deigned to tell me what he thought of my weekly musings. I don’t remember exactly what he said, but I do recall that the most flattering opinion he offered was that, though well-written, my columns were a bit on the “ahistorical side.”
It was a confounding conversation that left me fuming until I got a note from him the next day with more flattering assessment than he managed to utter in person. It was a warm note of congratulations. Along with a promise of a raise beginning the following week, he included this mysteriously scribbled line: “apropos of nothing.” If I’m able to find that letter, I’m going to frame it.
Years later, John would insist that I was misremembering his level of enthusiasm and that he had been “a fan” of the column from the beginning. I was pleased to hear it years later, though half suspected there was a little revisionism going on. Those early columns were mostly about the cops, gang warfare on the East End, mockery of national and local elected officials, skepticism about black political leadership and light-hearted vignettes about my wife (whom I never named in the column), my Grandma and my three sons.
In response to almost everything I wrote, hate mail poured in from across the political spectrum. Doctrinaire Democrats didn’t appreciate the fact that I didn’t toe the line when it came to the Clintons. White folks who resented seeing a black columnist’s face staring up at them from their newspapers several times a week demanded that the PG fire the “affirmative action hire” who “couldn’t write as well as the average fifth-grader.” Hamster lovers hated me for a 2000 column about our family’s procedure for dealing with a gravely ill rodent. When the Bush years kicked in, I began catching hell from fake conservatives who loved the Big Government and the surveillance state when it was spying on ordinary citizens and waging war against a country that never attacked us.
If you think some readers are too dense to comprehend my use of irony and sarcasm now even after two decades, the idiocy that buttressed many of the complaints about the column in the first decade would have made you weep. Alas, reading comprehension has never been a prerequisite to be a hater. Once a generation of sclerotic codgers and unreconstructed racists learned how to use email and set up fake Facebook accounts, they couldn’t wait to declare their ignorance while hiding behind new names and avatars.
I bring this up now because I’ve noticed a trend of willful stupidity in the online comments section of this column. There are mounting complaints about my “bias” and lack of political balance. Some readers want to know why I’m not as savage in criticizing Hillary Clinton as I am in smacking Donald Trump around. There’s an inability to differentiate between what a columnist does — express an opinion —and what straight news reporters do, which is to withhold theirs.
By all means, argue about whether I’m a good columnist or not, but let’s have no more complaints about my bias. I’m paid to express my opinion in a way I hope is both entertaining and informative. I pick my own subjects. I’m black, so I take a particular interest in black people and their experiences in America. If you can’t deal with that, then stop reading the column. I came of age in the 1960s and ’70s, so I see things through a prism of civil rights activism and the dismantling of institutional racism. I’m a liberal. Dostoevsky is my favorite writer. “Annie Hall” is my favorite movie. My ideal job would be to write comic books. I hate anything that smells even remotely of fascism. Capiche?
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @TonyNormanPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.