Maybe this is what it means to live in the post-Roger Ailes era if you’re a conservative. Maybe extremely bombastic personalities like Bill O’Reilly of Fox News are doomed to be “misunderstood” by the public going forward.
Without someone on the level of Mr. Ailes, the former CEO of Fox News, stepping in occasionally to prevent unforced errors like this week’s “well-fed” slaves controversy, Bill O’Reilly may be left to spout off his own odd notions unfiltered for the first time in his career as a cable news pundit.
Not that Mr. Ailes was some sort of moral compass, given the allegations of sexual harassment that led to his removal from the cable news empire he built, but surely he would’ve seen the folly of a privileged white guy like Bill O’Reilly attempting to provide “historical context” to Michelle Obama’s Monday night speech at the Democratic convention, in which she referred to the slave labor used to build the White House.
Without overtly defending chattel slavery in America, Mr. O’Reilly told his viewers that the slaves who helped build the White House were “well-fed” and had adequate lodging provided by the federal government.
The historical bogusness of that factoid aside, Mr. O’Reilly insisted that his intention was not to mitigate the horror of slavery.
In his own way, Mr. O’Reilly saw himself as bolstering Ms. Obama’s point by confirming that slaves were part of the workforce, though he might quibble with whether they were the majority of workers.
The elderly white folks who make up the bulk of Mr. O’Reilly’s audience needed to hear that it wasn’t only blacks pressed into service to build the White House. Ms. Obama’s comments had made their heads explode from the accumulated weight of historical denial.
In keeping with the lies America tells itself about its origins, the slaves who built the White House and carved Washington, D.C., out of fetid swampland should always be portrayed as part of a well-compensated fraternity of happy artisans, builders and non-Hispanic immigrant labor who toiled for years out of patriotic duty.
Mr. O’Reilly, a bestselling author who specializes in a trivialized, feel-good version of American history, knows this is what his viewers want to hear. He stumbled in delivering that message this week because “dishonest” critics and liberals purposely misunderstood his point, which, at best, was nonsensical and factually irrelevant.
Meanwhile, Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump also claims to be the victim of “dishonest critics” because of what many believe is a sincere invitation to the Russians to release the emails missing from Hillary Clinton’s private server, which they probably already have hacked.
The recent WikiLeaks dump of thousands of documents showed the lengths to which the Democratic National Committee went to undermine Bernie Sanders’ presidential run. While Julian Assange won’t name his source, it’s logical to suspect Russia. The whole affair looks suspiciously like an attempt by Russia to ensure a Trump victory.
His fawning words about Vladimir Putin aside, Mr. Trump denies any collusion with the Russian strongman whom he claims he has never met and doesn’t know, yet somehow managed to enter into a mutual admiration pact with during the last year.
At a disastrous morning news conference on Wednesday in which he said far more wacky things than usual, Mr. Trump seemed to openly condone espionage by the Russians that could sway the election his way. That’s how his words were interpreted by most observers.
The Democrats had a field day painting Mr. Trump as Russian stooge.
It didn’t help that the billionaire candidate has made recent statements saying that if he’s elected president, he might recognize Russia’s annexation of Crimea or pull out of NATO if its members don’t pay America more protection money to remain in the alliance.
Rumors that Mr. Trump’s reluctance to release his tax records because the public would then learn the degree of his indebtedness to Russian oligarchs are just starting to circulate.
Who knows whether there is any truth to them, given the bad shape Trump’s various businesses are supposed to be in. Could an inability to get cheap loans here motivate Mr. Trump to do business with unsavory characters around the world? It doesn’t seem unthinkable.
Mr. Trump’s attempt to characterize his news conference appeal to Russia as “sarcasm” and not a serious call for foreign interference in an American election may or may not be the truth, but his indifference to political norms most take for granted, combined with his overwhelming ignorance and narcissism, makes it impossible to give him the benefit of the doubt.
Do I think Donald Trump is in league with the Russians? I doubt it. He isn’t clever enough to be a convincing Manchurian candidate, but he might make a passable dupe for Vladimir Putin if he puts his mind to it.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @TonyNormanPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.