By natural disposition and life experience, Sen. Tim Scott of South Carolina is a conservative. By political affiliation, he’s a Republican. He’s been a loyal member of a blood-red caucus of Southern Republicans who make no secret of their contempt of much of the “liberal agenda” from guns to global warming.
When Mr. Scott was a member of the House of Representatives, he rarely broke with his fellow Republicans on any issue. He’s always been a conservative’s conservative — someone who could be trotted out at GOP conventions as proof that the party is far more open-minded than it’s given credit for when it comes to race.
By accident of birth and the vagaries of South Carolina primary politics, he is the first black senator from the South since Reconstruction. Though initially appointed to his Senate seat, Mr. Scott has since earned it by votes.
So imagine the surprise of many of his constituents when he took to the floor of the Senate on Wednesday to make a speech about race and policing in America that could’ve come from the mouth of any liberal Democrat.
“There is a deep divide between the black community and law enforcement — a trust gap,” Mr. Scott said. “We cannot ignore these issues. Because while so many officers do good — and we should be very thankful in support of all those officers that do good — some simply do not. I’ve experienced it myself.”
He then spoke of “shuddering” when he saw footage of the strangulation of Eric Garner in New York two years ago. He said he wept over footage of Walter Scott being shot in the back in North Charleston, S.C., last year. He admits that there was little time for Senate dignity when he heard the 4-year-old daughter of Philando Castille’s girlfriend trying to comfort her mother after the July 6 fatal shooting of Mr. Castille in suburban St. Paul, Minn. There were genuine tears of indignation when he saw the cell phone video of the incident. He confessed to “breaking down” at that point.
This is not how conservatives typically talk about policing in America. Somehow, Mr. Scott found the moral conviction to break with his party and speak of the humiliations that even a black conservative such as himself gets to experience along with other African Americans under similar circumstances.
“In the course of one year, I’ve been stopped seven times by law enforcement officers,” he said. “Was I speeding sometimes? Sure,” he said flashing two fingers, “but the vast majority of the time, I was pulled over for nothing more than driving a new car in the wrong neighborhood, or some other reason just as trivial.”
He then segued into a story about trying to enter a federal office building last year and initially being rebuffed by a guard who questioned his right to wear a pin identifying him as a U.S. senator.
“The pin, I know,” the guard said. “You, I don’t. Show me your ID.”
Mr. Scott had had enough. “Well, I’ll tell you that later that evening I received a phone call from his supervisor apologizing for the behavior. Mr. President, that is at least the third phone call that I’ve received from a supervisor or the chief of police since I’ve been in the Senate,” he said.
It was essentially the same story that more liberal members of the Congressional Black Caucus have been reciting for years to the jeers and hoots of skeptical colleagues, who accused them of “exaggerating.” Is Mr. Scott exaggerating?
He then told a story that spoke to the stubbornness of racism in general that had nothing to do with cops per se, but everything to do with institutional bias. He said he tried to attend an unnamed event at an unnamed establishment with two of his Senate staffers and two white officers. His aides were allowed in, but he was barred at the door.
Instead of insisting on admission, Mr. Scott and the white officers left in disgust. Why he chose not to embarrass the event and institution by naming them is beyond me, but the important thing is that he shared his outrage with the nation this week.
Remember, this was not Jesse Jackson, Rev. Al Sharpton or some easily demonized member of Black Lives Matter — this was Sen. Tim Scott, a solidly red conservative talking about the reality of racism like a Democrat. How does the Republican narrative that racism “ended” in the ‘60s or with President Barack Obama’s election square with his experience? Is Mr. Scott lying, too?
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.