When Beyonce takes the stage at Heinz Field next week, there will be plenty of police on hand to maintain order. Despite calls for a boycott of Beyonce’s national tour by a minority of police officers upset with the singer for allegedly expressing sentiments hostile to law enforcement during her Super Bowl halftime performance, there simply aren’t enough ill-informed cops to make such a boycott effective.

The off-duty cops who agreed to work the show are demonstrating a capacity for discernment that completely eludes their boycotting colleagues. Those officers smart enough to make distinctions between real and perceived threats understand that a phalanx of afro-wearing dancers in black leather, berets and bandoliers high-stepping during a performance of “Formation” are no more indicative of Beyonce’s allegiance to Black Panthers-style militancy than “I Shot the Sheriff” was a declaration of Bob Marley’s intent to kill all sheriffs and deputies.

It is difficult to imagine the cluelessness it takes to believe Beyonce Knowles, the former lead singer of Destiny’s Child, is fomenting a revolution against anything. Along with her husband Jay Z, Beyonce has been regularly called out by veteran civil rights activist Harry Belafonte for being indifferent to the plight of poor people. Yet some officers and many Fraternal Order of Police representatives regularly work themselves into a lather over the perception that the biggest diva in pop music is out to get them.

Periodically, the FOP and its low-information, terminally un-hip minions get it in their heads to “teach” a national rock or rap act that their feelings aren’t to be trifled with. Way back in 1989, they tried — and failed — to intimidate N.W.A. into not performing “[Expletive] tha’ Police” in concert. The rap group ignored them and a warning from the FBI, but was finally arrested in Detroit for disturbing the peace by partially performing the song. A few hours in custody until someone realized how unconstitutional it was to arrest them only added to their legend, their notoriety and their bottom line.

Advertise with us

The Patrolmen’s Benevolent Association of New York called for a boycott of all 10 of Bruce Springsteen’s Madison Square Garden shows in 2000 because they were offended that the singer questioned the shooting of Amadou Diallo in the song “American Skin (41 Shots).” Though there were scattered boos during some performances, the boycott showed the ineffectiveness of targeting popular singers. People instinctively understood that in its totality, Mr. Springsteen’s work has always shown empathy with working people — including cops. This was at odds with the way his songs were being characterized by hysterical cops. Fortunately, most cops ignored the boycott in that case, too.

For her part, Beyonce has learned to make the sour lemons of police protests into “Lemonade” — the name of her latest chart-topping album. In Miami, the first stop in her “Formation” tour, Beyonce debuted a line of $45 concert T-shirts with the legend “Boycott Beyonce” emblazoned on them. No one appreciates the irony of this fashion statement more than Queen Bey’s fans, so the shirts sell briskly whether there is an actual threat of a boycott or not. Beyonce isn’t the first pop culture icon to figure out a way to get rich off of the cluelessness of her critics, but she is easily the most stylish.

It goes without saying that the kind of cop who would be susceptible to the argument that Beyonce is advocating violence against police really isn’t the kind of cop who should be working a show where there are lots of black people, young people of all colors — or any sentient beings for that matter. That level of openness to demagoguery signals an unfamiliarity with cultural touchstones and an imperviousness to logic and commonsense. Such a person shouldn’t be a police officer in a diverse society where fluency, empathy and understanding of even unpopular ideas should be mandatory.

The protesting cops have raised an apolitical singer’s profile in ways that help her to market both a critically acclaimed album and a much-anticipated concert tour. It couldn’t have worked out any better for Beyonce than if she had paid the police to “protest” her tour. The goodwill generated by a misguided police boycott is incalculable. Beyonce is one of the biggest selling mainstream artists in the world. So what do some police groups hope to achieve by demonizing her in a way that puts more money in her pockets? It is a baffling strategy.

I would go so far as to suggest that the absence of women — especially black women — in the upper ranks of fraternal police organizations calling for boycotts against a black feminist icon like Beyonce is why such monumentally silly protests happen in the first place. One woman laughing at the suggestion of a boycott of Beyonce would’ve stopped the nonsense in its tracks.

Advertise with us

Fortunately, the officers who will be working Beyonce’s show next week not only “get” her music, but also have children, siblings and friends who know the difference between hype and hysteria. The only thing Beyonce is a “threat” to is your ability to hold onto your money. Premium Beyonce concert tickets are among the most expensive in the business. The demand created by controversy, even when it is totally manufactured, isn’t cheap.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @TonyNormanPG.