There’s not a more popular Founding Father in the American imagination right now than Alexander Hamilton, our nation’s first secretary of the treasury and the unlikely hero of “Hamilton,” the phenomenal Broadway musical created by and starring Lin-Manuel Miranda.
It’s been said that it’s easier to get into Harvard than to score tickets to a Saturday night performance. Because the show has been sold out for months, dozens, sometimes hundreds of fans line up daily for the lottery at the Richard Rodgers Theatre hoping that not every ticket has fallen into the hands of unscrupulous brokers.
Inspired by historian Ron Chernow’s magisterial 2004 biography “Alexander Hamilton,” Mr. Miranda, a Hispanic actor whose parents are from Puerto Rico, wrote a rap song based on Hamilton’s life that he later expanded into the musical we know today. Realizing he had something special on his hands, Mr. Miranda cast himself in the role of the title character he knows he wouldn’t have had a shot at had he not written the role himself.
But he didn’t stop there. He then assigned the roles of the other dead white men (and women) to the most talented, but criminally underused actors of color he could find. He enticed them all with promises of steady employment and a clever scheme to subvert audience expectations with a multi-ethnic take on the founding of the Republic.
Because audiences always expect to see white actors in such iconic roles, “Hamilton” quickly made history by casting African-Americans as George Washington and Aaron Burr; a Hispanic man plays John Laurens, an Asian-American woman plays Eliza Hamilton; and a biracial rapper of black and Jewish extraction plays both Lafayette and Thomas Jefferson. Only King George is played by a white actor.
Mr. Miranda, in collaboration with The Roots, also composed the music and lyrics, an indelible mix of songs inspired by hip-hop, rhythm and blues, classic rock, island music and Broadway show tunes. A few of the songs like “Wait For It,” “My Shot,” “Satisfied” and “The Schuyler Sisters” are fated to become staples of the Great American Songbook apart from the musical itself. The music is a character itself, requiring actors who can rap as well as sing to do it justice.
Last week, “Hamilton” announced open auditions in New York, San Francisco and Los Angeles. The ad caused quite a bit of consternation because of one line: “Seeking NON-WHITE men and women, ages 20s to 30s, for Broadway and upcoming tours.” Actors’ Equity Association, the union representing theater actors, objected. The Alliance for Inclusion in the Arts said the ad violated the New York City Human Rights Law because it was racially exclusionary on its face.
The producers of the show quickly amended the language to bring it into conformity with the law. Now every actor regardless of racial background is welcome to audition for any role, but it isn’t likely that principal roles conceived with non-white actors in mind will depart from that tradition. The diversity onstage every night in “Hamilton” is a big part of its phenomenal appeal. The musical’s DNA is steeped in hip-hop and urban brashness. It will look, feel and sound incongruous if it starts to look like every other play and musical on Broadway.
When I first heard that there was considerable angst about the original casting call, and even veiled threats of lawsuits by “disenfranchised” white actors, I scoffed at the audacity and the irony of that reaction. After all, “Hamilton” was an antidote to the unbearable whiteness of much of contemporary American theater.
Even so, I couldn’t begrudge an ambitious actor his or her desire to be a part of such a genuinely American spectacle. Just as non-white actors in “Hamilton” insist the musical has helped them “claim” the Founders as their own, white actors and predominantly white audiences are able to see in a tangible way how black music and non-white actors fit into the American narrative. It is no longer a leap of the imagination to see American history as biracial. Everyone wants a piece of that action.
One day I’m going to feel comfortable with white guys in the lead roles of “Hamilton,” I suppose — but not yet. I’ll never be comfortable with an all-white version of the musical unless it is staged by suburban high schools with a dearth of non-white students. I know that suburban kids of all colors are invested in hip-hop and speak the language as fluently as inner-city kids. They’re just as qualified to be on stage singing it. Because of this, we’re moving toward a popular culture that is far more open and accepting of difference than it is now.
In the meantime, a production like “Hamilton” still needs the irony of history and expectation staring it in the face to work. In its current form, the musical contradicts the tyranny of race by radically universalizing American history. For the two hours that it is performed by its non-white cast, all Americans are able to see themselves on that stage. That’s quite an achievement for a humble musical.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.
Correction (April 5): This column has been updated to state that Alexander Hamilton served as secretary of the treasury, not secretary of state.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.