Saturday at an unknown time, Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, resplendent in pajamas appropriate for a 79-year-old spending his last night on Earth, raised the stakes of the 2016 presidential race by dying. Justice Scalia shuffled from this mortal coil peacefully, though the circumstances of expending his last breath at a remote Texas resort owned by a millionaire businessman who has supported many Democrats is already being cast in the most diabolical light possible.

Because Justice Scalia was the guest of honor at a private gathering with 35 wealthy people whose identities will probably never be known, we have to rely on Houston businessman John B. Poindexter’s account of what happened. An afternoon of blue quail hunting at the Cibolo Creek Ranch had given way to a festive dinner with the other guests. Still in good spirits, Justice Scalia turned in around 9 p.m. Friday. He was assigned the “El Presidente” suite.

On Saturday morning, Mr. Poindexter discovered Justice Scalia’s body an hour or so before noon after several polite knocks earlier had failed to rouse him. After that, the day continued going downhill for the discombobulated host. He couldn’t locate officials in the remote region an hour from the Mexican border who could officially pronounce his honored guest dead. There were no U.S. Marshals on hand to help initially, because Justice Scalia had declined their protection.

It was left to Presidio County Judge Cinderela Guevara to do the honors over the phone without actually seeing Judge Scalia’s body. This in itself will become the source of a thousand conspiracy theories in a few days. Still, as unremarkable as the circumstances of Justice Scalia’s death actually were, there was nothing routine about getting his death certified in an orderly way. This is the kind of historical irony that would have irritated the late jurist, a self-styled “Originalist” who believed in the primacy of the plain meaning of legal texts to sort truth from falsehood.

Advertise with us

Mr. Poindexter also was left with a heck of a public relations problem. How, exactly, does one break the news to a polarized nation in the middle of a contentious presidential election that the U.S. Supreme Court’s most conservative justice was found dead on a Democrat’s ranch? Add to these embarrassing circumstances the Scalia family’s refusal to allow an autopsy to determine his exact cause of death.

The sketchiness of the circumstances can’t help but provide endless fodder to the nation’s right-wing conspiracy manufacturing complex. That’s why the Drudge Report settled on a snarky headline that insinuated the worst possible interpretation of the justice’s death: “Scalia Found Dead ‘With Pillow Over Head.’ ”

For the next week, or at least until Justice Scalia is buried, there will be endless reams of nonsense about how the contentious jurist was one of the greatest legal minds in American history. His wit and superior writing skills will be endlessly gushed over in isolation from the crushing social Darwinism he advocated. The brutal logic of both his majority opinions and acerbic dissents will be partially obscured by the hagiography of the chattering class eager to appear nonpartisan in the wake of his death.

Meanwhile, the Republican-controlled U.S. Senate has vowed to oppose President Barack Obama’s constitutional prerogative to send a nominee before them to replace Justice Scalia. With Justice Scalia’s death, the U.S. Supreme Court has a 4-4 ideological split. The Republicans argue that such a stalemate is fine until a new president can name a nominee sometime in 2017. They believe America can live with a little chaos in the high court until a Republican gets into office. After all, Congress has operated as a completely dysfunctional institution for years under Mr. Obama. What’s another year or so of gridlock, this time involving all three branches of government?

I hope Mr. Obama has a coherent strategy for exposing the nihilism of the Republican Party for what it is. A once-great political party is attempting to politicize what should be a routine exercise of the U.S. Senate’s advise-and-consent powers. The absurdity of the rumors surrounding Justice Scalia’s death are exceeded only by the cynicism of those who believe the country will sit idly by while the Supreme Court is held hostage by the basest of election-year politics.

Advertise with us

Enough is enough. There will be a reckoning in November that few currently plotting a season of disruption will have scarcely imagined a week ago.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @TonyNormanPG.