There’s something about the death of a musical icon that obligates those of us who write for a living to temper unadulterated fannishness with critical assessment despite the lump in our throats. Coming across as merely maudlin when the object of our affection trafficked in so much aesthetic complexity would feel like a betrayal.

But it is nearly impossible to pay tribute to David Bowie without resorting to some tawdry origin story involving first contact with his music. In my case, Mr. Bowie was originally part of a package deal with Iggy Pop and Alice Cooper that fell in my lap thanks to my best friend David’s nascent fascination with glam rock.

Still, if it weren’t for the FM radio format that was just starting to liberate young minds like mine, Mr. Bowie’s music would have been doomed to exist on the periphery of a bland musical constellation consisting of mostly radio-friendly soul and rock ballads on AM radio at the time. Still, encountering the Bowie persona without a frame of reference that could easily make sense of what he was doing put me at a disadvantage in the early 1970s when “Ziggy Stardust,” “Aladdin Sane” and “Diamond Dogs” first enthralled my small circle of friends.

It was only when I began to grow as a visual artist in the mid-to-late 1970s did I fully appreciate what it was my West Philly posse saw in the androgynous shape-shifter years earlier. First, I had to shed a lot of idiotic cultural baggage including misplaced prejudice against dudes wearing mascara (unless they were Alice Cooper, who, mysteriously, always got a pass from me).

Advertise with us

I think the great icebreaker for me were the verses from 1975’s “Young Americans” single that got lots of play on all radio formats: “You ain’t a pimp and you ain’t a hustler / A pimp’s got a Caddy and a lady got a Chrysler / Black’s got respect, and white’s got his ‘Soul Train’ / Mama’s got cramps, and look at your hands ache.”

For years, I misheard one of those verses as “whites got on ‘Soul Train,’ ” which just happened to be the case at the time. I gave Mr. Bowie a lot of credit for contributing to the breaking down of some of the apartheid that had ossified radio formats. If whites could get on “Soul Train,” I figured, then blacks could listen to Yes and the Alan Parsons Project without embarrassment.

In high school, I quickly noticed that every creative person I associated with or admired referenced David Bowie in some way. They spoke admiringly of the mercurial nature of creativity that the singer embodied. Even when Mr. Bowie said questionable things about fascism, there was a tendency to give him the benefit of the doubt because he was so many leagues ahead of the rest of us. At worst, it was probably just the heroin and cocaine talking.

The last time I saw David Bowie in live performance was at Star Lake Amphitheater, Sept. 23, 1995. He was the headliner on a bill that included Nine Inch Nails, led by Trent Reznor of Mercer, Pa. Mr. Reznor’s band was one of the hottest acts in rock music at the time and the primary reason that 13,000 young people obsessed with goth imagery and black clothing turned out on such a chilly evening.

In my review of the show, I took note of the fact that Mr. Bowie ignored his vast back catalog and stuck to new, but unfamiliar songs. He was rewarded by the incorrigible crowd with tepid applause at best. I admired his unwillingness to grovel before an audience that considered Marilyn Manson some kind of messiah. Still, I would’ve appreciated the show a lot more had he condescended to play a few hits, like “Young Americans,” he was way too cool to play.

Advertise with us

On Saturday, I picked up a copy of Mr. Bowie’s latest CD, “Blackstar,” which had been released on his 69th birthday the day before. Though touted as David Bowie’s “jazz album,” it didn’t strike me as jazz so much as mournful vocals over a bed of sometimes intriguing instrumental arrangements. I put it away after one play with plans to return to it. What I assumed would be a minor work in his catalog is now destined to be his epitaph.

Because of Mr. Bowie’s track record, I generally buy his albums before I’ve even heard a single note. I may not particularly like what he’s doing at the time, but there’s something about his approach to the art and craft of music that always feels elemental and invigorating. He never faked his way through an album. He willingly risked total failure rather than settle for the predictable.

On Monday, I woke to news that David Bowie was dead. There’s something about stringing those words together in a sentence that just doesn’t feel right.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.