I’m a big fan of Canada. Half of my college roommates were Canadians. Before I married a gal from Pittsburgh, I assumed I would end up with one of the casually lefty Canadian types I crossed paths with in college. Besides the women, I was attracted to Canada’s promise of a far more humane bohemianism in southern Ontario than was then available in New York or Philly, my hometown, in the 1980s.
The American put-down about Canadians being “boring” never made much sense to me, especially back then. That nation’s enviable health care system and low crime rate coupled with its lack of messy foreign entanglements, insane domestic political gridlock and failure to tolerate an unrestricted gun culture made Canadians appear eminently rational and more interesting to me. They were anything but boring. I used to hope in vain that America would eventually evolve into a more “boring” place like Canada. If there is any kind of exceptionalism I associate with Canadians, it is their relentless politeness and mania for hospitality.
My old infatuation with our neighbors to the north was triggered again recently by news coverage of that country’s gracious reception of Syrian refugees who arrived in that country last week. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau personally greeted the first planeload of 163 refugees out of the expected 25,000 Canada has agreed to take in.
“You’re safe at home now,” Mr. Trudeau said as he welcomed the weary immigrants as they disembarked. Being met by their new country’s leader so soon after the vagaries of living in a war zone must have seemed surreal to them. After all, their last president tried to drop barrel bombs on them.
Escaping the barbarity of ISIS and the chaos of an intractable civil war in the land of their birth wasn’t easy, but by some miracle they managed to end up as new residents of North America’s most humane country.
“Tonight, they step off the plane as refugees, but they walk out of this terminal as permanent residents of Canada,” Mr. Trudeau said to gathered media and government officials. Even without the specter of xenophobia that has turned the American political scene into an echo chamber of Donald Trump’s darkest musings about foreigners, it would be difficult to picture President Barack Obama — or any American president — making the kind of gesture that Mr. Trudeau offered.
In contrast, America has agreed to take in 10,000 Syrian refugees. Because of fierce domestic political resistance during this election year, the vetting process for each refugee is expected to become exponentially more onerous. The recent terror attacks in Paris and San Bernardino, Calif., have transformed Muslim refugees seeking safety into a terrifying “other” who are presumed guilty until a rigorous background check clears them.
Obviously, some caution is warranted. The Islamic State has made no secret of its desires to infiltrate the ranks of refugees to slip into the West, even though many of its followers already hold valid passports to these nations. Opportunism and war have gone hand in hand for thousands of years. Still, an exaggerated fear of Syrian refugees is being fomented by Mr. Trump and his rivals for the Republican presidential nomination. Mr. Trump has even gone so far as to compare the Syrian refugees to the mythical Trojan Horse, hoping that his supporters are dumb enough to take him literally.
When it comes to welcoming the refugees, it’s easy to be embarrassed by the contrast in styles between our two countries. Some states — the usual suspects — have governors who say they will resist refugee resettlement. Their reaction is reminiscent of the irrationality and paranoia that greeted American medical volunteers returning from Africa after helping those stricken by the Ebola crisis.
America hasn’t always been as xenophobic as it is now, though we’ve frequently wrestled with shameful nativist impulses. The feel-good stories coming out of Canada regarding Syrian refugee resettlement should embarrass us. As a nation, we’ve proved innumerable times we have the capacity to be just as generous to refugees as our Canadian neighbors. Recently, we’ve given in to our darkest fears because those vying for power in our democracy are cowards and demagogues.
Maybe the Statue of Liberty should relocate to the other side of Niagara Falls until we recover our national nerve.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.