Last week, pop culture pundits took note of the fact that the day Michael J. Fox’s Marty McFly character materialized in “the future” had finally arrived.
In the 1989 sci-fi comedy classic “Back to the Future II,” Marty McFly and his mad scientist mentor, Emmett “Doc” Brown, were transported from Reagan era 1985 to Oct. 21, 2015, in a plutonium-powered DeLorean.
Marty and Doc’s fictional arrival day was enough to launch dozens of think pieces on what “Back to the Future II” got right or wrong about our time. For its part, The New York Times went in another direction entirely with a provocative question that has more in common with the original “Back to the Future.”
In that film, the intrepid time travelers journeyed back to 1955, when Marty’s parents were supposed to fall in love in high school. The only way Marty can ensure that he’ll come into existence one day is to play matchmaker to his otherwise incompatible parents. The film uses the age-old philosophical question of what past events a person would change if it were possible to travel back in time.
Riffing anew on that very topic, The New York Times Magazine posed the following question to its readers: Would you kill a baby Hitler if you had the chance?
The poll results were fascinating. Forty-two percent of readers who responded would be willing to do so. Thirty percent ruled out the possibility of killing Baby Hitler, and 28 percent were unsure. Killing baby Hitler before he had actually done anything evil in the world carried the day in the poll, though without a clear majority, let alone a “moral” one.
More people than I expected admitted that they would resort to infanticide to spare the world the horror of Hitler and the Holocaust. I suspect that most of the 28 percent who said they weren’t sure what they would do are really in the “Kill Baby Hitler” camp, but don’t want to admit it. The actual baby pictures of Hitler that were floating around the Web last week didn’t make the decision to kill him an easy one.
I didn’t vote in the Times poll, but if I did, I would’ve voted “No” to killing Baby Hitler. I know — typical liberal hypocrisy, right? But I don’t subscribe to the theory that Hitler was some extraordinary solo act and that World War II wouldn’t have happened without him. I wouldn’t be in a hurry to slip into his nursery in the middle of an Austrian night in 1889 with dagger drawn.
The idea that killing Hitler as an infant would somehow have prevented Nazism from being born is simple-minded. Many centuries of murderous anti-Semitism preceded Hitler’s birth, though his talent for convincing the population of a modern state in the heart of Christian Europe to devote its industrial ingenuity to genocide and military expansion was unprecedented.
Still, smothering Hitler in his crib wouldn’t have necessarily snuffed out the spirit of intolerance that infected the West at the time. Even adding Goebbels, Goering, Eichmann and hundreds of other leaders of the German high command to the baby hit list would have only slowed Nazism down until another bunch of misanthropes and psychopaths stepped forward to give birth to the Reich decades later.
Meanwhile, that’s an awful lot of infant blood to have on one’s hands — enough to erase the moral distinction between the mass murderer and the potential Nazis he or she killed.
But I’m a reasonable guy. If I were somehow transported to the beer hall when Hitler and most of his lieutenants gathered in the 1920s and 1930s to plot his election as Germany’s chancellor, I would be a lot less squeamish about doing whatever had to be done.
Even my hero, the German theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer, joined a conspiracy to assassinate Hitler during the war’s height. The plot was uncovered, and he was hanged mere days before his prison camp was liberated by the Allies. Still, I’m under no illusion that an act of terrorism, even for a good cause, is somehow morally superior to killing babies in their cribs.
The question of killing Baby Hitler is an interesting thought experiment. It is fascinating in the way it upends political convention by putting ostensibly pro-life people in a position of sanctioning infanticide. It also puts pro-choice Americans in the uncomfortable position of refusing to kill Baby Hitler.
The irony is deafening. Call it “Back to the Fuhrer.” It would probably make a helluva movie.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.