Last Friday at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary, the Rev. Naim Ateek, a Palestinian Christian, spoke from a very broken heart about the dim prospect for peace in the conflict-riven land of his birth.

The attacks on Israelis in Jerusalem by knife-wielding Palestinians of both genders and the revenge attacks on Palestinians and Arab citizens by Israelis weighed heavily on him.

By the time the Holy Land’s bloodiest month this year ended, the death toll included 41 Palestinians, eight Israelis and an Eritrean bystander mistaken for a terrorist by an enraged mob. Addressing the local audience, Rev. Ateek tried to connect the daily reality of Israel-Palestine to the heart of his faith’s radical, non-negotiable mandate — love your enemies and do good to those who persecute you.

He was keynote speaker at a conference hosted by the World Mission Initiative and Metro Urban Institute, which was called “We Refuse to be Enemies: Struggle for a Just Peace in Palestine-Israel.” Even in relatively non-bloody times when Israelis and Palestinians are content to pretend the other doesn’t exist, delivering such a speech would be a struggle. People on both sides of the Israel-Palestine question hold peacemakers like Rev. Ateek in utter contempt.

Advertise with us

He said that seeing Palestinians carrying out violent acts in the streets of Jerusalem when they were no match for the Israel Defense Forces pained him. He conceded that his generation of Palestinian activists, academics and spiritual leaders had failed to pass on the tangible benefits of non-violent resistance to young people for whom humiliation and despair were as familiar as their own names.

Still, Rev. Ateek’s words resonated with me as news out of Jerusalem over the weekend conspired to make any appeal to peace in that God-haunted land sound hopelessly perverse.

The founder of the Sabeel Ecumenical Liberation Theology Center in Jerusalem, he spoke of the biblical mandate to treat sojourners and “strangers in the land” with a special respect that was missing from the interactions of modern Palestinians and Israelis. They each claim the land, but because of a history of terrorism and military occupation, they refuse to show any such hospitality or forbearance, much less love.

“We refuse to be enemies,” Rev. Ateek said, echoing the theme of the conference for emphasis. He said seeking peace even in a violent land was the epitome of faith and courage.

“This does not make us weak,” he insisted. He said pursuing justice and mercy doesn’t mean passively accepting injustice, “It means you refuse to hate.”

Advertise with us

Yet it sounds hollow when endless cycles of vengeance and a ruthless, irrational belief in the efficacy of violence represent the dominant religious and political ethic. Both sides believe that just a few more bodies on an altar already overflowing with blood will be enough to convince “the Other” to make the concessions necessary to stop violence in the Holy Land permanently.

Haftom Zarhum is the Eritrean migrant shot twice by a security guard and beset upon by a mob as he lay dying. The angry Israelis were convinced that he was in league with a Palestinian who had killed a soldier and wounded 10 others at a bus station in Beersheba. In this example of the illogic of modern scapegoating, there was no evidence of Mr. Zarhum’s guilt — just suspicion because he didn’t look enough like those who ended up assailing him.

Mr. Zarhum was clearly a stranger in the land even after having lived in Israel for three and a half years. He was in Beersheba to renew his work visa when someone erroneously identified him as the Palestinian’s accomplice. Unarmed and bleeding after being shot, he was at the crowd’s mercy. No hospitality was shown. He was spat upon, beaten, kicked in the head and died at the hospital.

“All the people gathering around the man attacked him. Nobody was helping him,” an unidentified and repentant participant in the assault told a reporter from a British newspaper. “People just were making sure he doesn’t move. There is no human being who did not kick or beat him. Everyone took part. I couldn’t sleep last night thinking about what happened, and I feel sick about myself.”

There should be plenty of soul-searching in Israel-Palestine over what amounts to an evil parody of Jesus’ parable of the good Samaritan. Instead, violence will continue to marginalize peacemakers because, well, the winning side is always just a few bodies away from ending the violence once and for all.