The most aggravating thing about l’affaire Kim Davis in Kentucky is witnessing the banality of what passes for Christianity these days.
There’s nothing like the spectacle of opportunists and scoundrels with tarnished halos claiming God’s moral authority as cover for the rankest shenanigans.
When U.S. District Judge David Bunning ordered Rowan County Clerk Kim Davis to cease her defiance of a federal court order and begin issuing marriage licenses to gay citizens, that should have been the end of it. Despite her fierce Apostolic faith, Ms. Davis should have complied. It is settled law.
In June, the U.S. Supreme Court determined that gays and lesbians must be accorded constitutional guarantees enjoyed by their fellow citizens, thus making marriage a civil right open to all. If marriage were still the exclusive domain of churches, synagogues, mosques or other religious institutions, then Ms. Davis could reasonably refuse to be put in a position to violate the sacredness of a religious rite as she understands it.
Last week, a gay citizen who met all of the civil requirements asked Ms. Davis by what authority she continued to deny him and his partner a marriage license. Without missing a beat and oblivious to the irony of her situation as an elected official, Ms. Davis told him that she did so “under the authority of God.”
Once again, God was dragged kicking and screaming into the most common of debased religious fantasies — the one that imagines that God is just teeny enough to be reduced to the sum total of one’s own picayune bigotries. Immediately, Ms. Davis became a hero to those whose God happens to have the same mix of cultural anxieties that they do.
Ms. Davis was sent to jail for refusing to execute the duties of her office. Conservative apologists, who can usually be counted on to preach law and order no matter what, constructed arguments that hold tightly to the principles of religious anarchy as a precedent for Ms. Davis’ defiance.
When Ms. Davis was released from jail after six days because five of her six deputies finally agreed to do their jobs, she basked in the adulation of a crowd as deluded as she was about the separation of church and state. At a rally organized by former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee, one of the nation’s leading theocrats, Ms. Davis claimed a victory for God and Jesus and urged Christians to never back down from their convictions.
Meanwhile, her employees agreed to do what she wouldn’t. Gays and lesbians can now get marriage licenses in Rowan County, Ky.
Because the weight of abiding by the law — and presumably the moral guilt that comes with it — is now on her deputies’ shoulders, Ms. Davis got what she really wanted out of the charade: a face-saving way to stand by her principles while continuing to collect her $80,000 annual salary until Jan. 7, 2019.
When Ms. Davis returns to work next week, don’t expect a peep out of her about “giving up everything” for God. She’s not so principled that she’s willing to give up one of the higher-paying jobs in Appalachia.
Still, Ms. Davis got me thinking about all the Christians out there who see a shred of truth in what she says, but not necessarily the “truth” as she interprets it. For Christians like myself, the “h-word” doesn’t stand for “homosexual” — it stands for “hypocrite,” a class of self-righteous believer Jesus never tired of railing against from a well of deep, visceral disdain.
Instead of embracing the hypocritical hermeneutic of those who cherry-pick what to be outraged about, imagine the anarchy that would engulf American society if Christians held every “Christian” elected official to the standards of New Testament-era Christianity with its rampant socialism, militant love of enemies and otherworldly disregard for the interests of the rich and the powerful.
How would the simple-minded binary of American politics deal with Jesus’ admonition to “put away one’s sword,” help widows and orphans in their distress, visit those languishing in prison, rescue the homeless and offer refuge to the strangers in our midst?
What if instead of tolerating the judgment of those like Ms. Davis who imagine homosexuality is a greater affront to God than their hypocrisy, we judged politicians by a higher standard than the cynical calculus of contemporary American politics? Lots of folks would suddenly begin believing in the separation of church and state if that happened, I’d wager.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.