Usually when a politician tries to be funny, it is a disaster.

Because pols are nothing if not the most ambitious of liars, their humor can come across as calculating or desperate. For all their attempts at self-deprecating wit, they’re rarely ever truly humble. It takes a certain amount of self-awareness to be truly hilarious. Consequently, it’s easier to laugh at politicians than laugh with them.

When I arrived at the 8th Annual Candidates’ Comedy Night at the Improv in Homestead last week, I wasn’t expecting much in the way of comedy from anyone except the charity event’s host — my colleague Gene Collier. Anyone who reads Gene’s column knows how funny he can be. Believe it or not, his stand-up routine is even funnier, though much of it can’t be repeated in the family newspaper that employs him.

Suffice to say, Gene has perfected a routine that showcases his ease with the subtleties of observational humor. He’s quick to acknowledge the absurdity of people and institutions, especially in Western Pennsylvania, without resorting to pointless mockery — the lingua franca of lesser comedians.

Advertise with us

Maybe it’s the hangdog expression he maintains on stage that makes everything that comes out of his mouth sound more hilarious than it might actually be, but Gene has always reminded me of a more humane and articulate version of comedian Steven Wright.

I knew I would enjoy his material, but imagine my shock when many of the politicos who graced the stage that night had me slapping my thighs in appreciation, too. Even the material that wouldn’t fit the standard definition of “funny” shined because of the sincerity of the joke-teller.

When Philadelphia Judge Kevin Dougherty, a Supreme Court candidate, asked the audience, “What do you call a Philadelphia Eagle with a Super Bowl ring?” you could almost feel the audience formulating the answer before he said it — “A thief.”

Sure, he was pandering to a room full of Steelers fans, but it was transparent and sincere pandering for a worthy cause. People don’t look quite as ridiculous when they undercut a little of their own dignity for the sake of a charity that benefits children.

Politicians such as Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and Allegheny County Republican Chairman Jim Roddey and a slew of candidates for statewide courts were among those taking the stage one by one, working material that would give most pols pause in the usual hurly-burly of political theater.

Advertise with us

The saving grace of such charity events has always been the willingness of the press corps to turn a blind eye to risque material uttered by politicians “for the sake of the kids.” There’s something liberating about watching normally cautious officials abandon their well-scrubbed and well-coiffed personas for a night of profane joking. Ironically, it makes them instantly more likable and relatable in ways that their constituents rarely see.

The highlight of the evening was, without a doubt, outgoing Philly Mayor Michael Nutter’s version of the Sugarhill Gang’s seminal “Rapper’s Delight.” Mr. Nutter stunned the capacity crowd with an exceptionally confident monologue that acknowledged the playful rivalry between Philly and Pittsburgh before morphing into a tight, finger-popping version of the rap classic.

When Mr. Nutter finished his rendition, he dropped the mic as a sign of his overwhelming triumph. He got a standing ovation for his trouble and hosannas from the well-heeled audience. It’s impossible to imagine any other politician in the state pulling it off with such urban swagger.

In the lobby after his performance, Mr. Nutter was surrounded by admiring Allegheny County pols and their significant others who wanted to be photographed with him. Though open-collared and sweating, Mr. Nutter cut a cool figure in a room full of buttoned-down attendees who jostled to pay their respects to the rapping mayor from Philly.

Between his congratulatory handshakes from impatient pols, Mr. Nutter and I traded vital stats about growing up in West Philly. We didn’t live that far away from each other, but our paths never crossed. At 58, he’s got a few years on me, but we share a similar set of pop cultural references and values. He’s a former DJ who championed urban music even as he pursued a political path.

Advertise with us

It was a great night filled with laughter and surprise in which I learned that some of our elected local officials are capable of shocking amounts of humanity after all.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.