Maybe I’m missing something here. I could’ve sworn that less than two months ago, the U.S. Supreme Court declared marriage equality the law of the land.

It wasn’t a unanimous verdict, but a 5-4 vote is usually pretty darn definitive and binding across these United States. I recall that the legalization of same-sex marriage was on the front page of every newspaper and on all the news channels. I swear I’m not making that up.

Yet, somehow I’ve been coming across contrary news stories with datelines from places in Alabama, Kentucky, Nebraska, Texas and Indiana. The headlines are always iterations of the same theme: “A clerk in such-and-such county (or city) refuses to issue marriage licenses in such-and-such county to same-sex couples because of religious convictions.”

I went to school in West Philly, so admittedly some of our textbooks may have been a tad out of date back in the ’70s, but the last time I took a geography test the five states where civil servants have gone rogue were still part of our grand national fabric.

Advertise with us

And if I understand the concept of separation of powers even a bit, the Supreme Court is the sole determiner of what laws we’re obliged to respect. This has been the case ever since the U.S. Constitution was ratified on June 21, 1788. Consequently, it isn’t up to civil service employees to withhold rights from American citizens based on their own sense of spiritual or secular propriety. They’re obligated to follow the law and respect the rights of American citizens seeking government services.

That’s why I’m scratching my head over these weird dispatches dribbling in from America’s heartland. Of all the issues that might prompt someone with a highly developed religious conscience to take a stand, why is same-sex marriage the Maginot Line of civil service duty?

Because I’m a liberal, I’ll allow for the possibility that some of my news sources employ a filter, but I’m reasonably certain that no clerk has ever refused to issue a marriage license to a heterosexual couple, even if one or both is divorced or currently living in sin. Serial marriage despoilers like Rush Limbaugh, Larry King and even the late, great Elizabeth Taylor never elicited as much as a raised eyebrow from a civil servant.

If the preservation of traditional marriage is the point of becoming a refusenik at the marriage license bureau, isn’t there something a tad hypocritical about condoning divorced citizens’ attempts to redefine marriage as “one person with the right to as many spouses as can be convinced to walk down the aisle over a lifetime”?

Isn’t each divorced person who is granted a marriage license ultimately mocking the “sacredness” of marriage, too? And what about those who are entering into marriage for the first time but are suspected of living lives of dubious morality? If Woody Allen and Soon-Yi Previn had applied to them for their marriage license, would any of these same clerks have treated one of America’s greatest movie directors so shabbily?

Advertise with us

Twenty-five states, including righteous Alabama, allow first cousins to marry. You never hear of clerks refusing to issue marriage licenses to them on the basis of a revulsion to incest. Aren’t kissing cousins an affront to the sacredness of marriage?

One would think that with all the attacks on public sector unions, especially in the red states, civil servants who refuse to follow the unambiguous dictates of the law would lose their jobs. Yet there appears to be tremendous sympathy and tolerance for these clerks. None of these lawless bureaucrats has been fired yet, which is saying something in states where governors pride themselves on shedding public employees.

These clerks are quick to claim they’re being persecuted for their faith, because same-sex couples have the temerity to come to their workplace and demand that they do their jobs. What am I missing here? Why is there even a question about whether people who refuse to do their government jobs should be immediately fired for cause?

I have plenty of sympathy for people who follow their consciences, even when I disagree with them. In this case, there is only one ethical thing for a person of conscience to do: If you disagree with the law because you believe God told you to discriminate against gay people, then you’re morally obligated to follow your conscience out the door.

You could always get a job in a gun shop in a Muslim-free zone or in a bakery that refuses to cater to sinners.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.