CHARLESTON, S.C. — Even before June 17, Mother Emanuel African Methodist Church was a big draw in downtown Charleston, S.C. Its Gothic Revival-style architecture has always made it one of the most distinctive buildings in the bustling retail and restaurant district along historic Calhoun Street.
This past Sunday morning, finding a parking space was more difficult than usual at Mother Emanuel. Dozens of people, mostly tourists and the merely curious, took pictures of themselves and loved ones in front of a sidewalk memorial to the nine murdered church members that renews itself daily with a mountain of fresh flowers.
Inside, Gov. Nikki Haley, her husband and their two children occupied the front pew. The Republican governor has been riding a wave of positive reviews lately for her leadership in facilitating the swift removal of the Confederate battle flag from the state Capitol grounds. She has been mentioned as a possible running mate on her party’s 2016 ticket.
A member of her security detail sat behind the first family, trying to blend in with the overwhelmingly black and female congregants who shared the row with him. Marine-stiff, his wariness began to relent as the mellifluous gospel music surged through the sanctuary with the force of a sonic boom.
Mother Emanuel is not air-conditioned, so paper fans were a-fluttering from the back of the balcony, where one half of the choir was installed, to the first floor, where the organist, the drummer, the trumpet player and the other half of the all-female choir held sway.
It was a humid morning, and most of Mother Emanuel’s 2,500 seats were filled.
While I listened to church announcements from the Rev. Norvel Goff Sr., the interim pastor, my eyes were drawn to a pair of disembodied praying hands on the stained-glass window behind the altar.
The painted mural to the right of the stained-glass hands featured an inexplicably twinkle-eyed Jesus who bears no resemblance to the kind of men who palled around in Palestine 2,000 years ago.
By any standard, a white Jesus feels like a bad fit for a congregation led in the early 1800s by Denmark Vesey, whose appetite for slave rebellion resulted in the torching of the church and the execution of 35 of its members in 1822.
While contemplating this mystery, I was roused from my reverie when I heard a reference to Hootie and the Blowfish. Rev. Goff announced that the South Carolina band, which is once again playing shows in the region, sent a check for $50,000 to the church to support its music ministry and choir.
“Quite frankly,” Rev. Goff said not too persuasively, “I’ll be listening to more Hootie and the Blowfish in the future.” The audience laughed as it applauded the “bro’ rock” band’s generosity.
I finally recognized Rev. Goff’s boss, the AME’s presiding prelate, the Rt. Rev. Richard Franklin Norris, when he got up to speak. When President Barack Obama belted out a spontaneous version of “Amazing Grace” at a service in June for one of the shooting victims, Rev. Norris stood next to him as a gesture of quiet encouragement. It was one of the most iconic moments of Mr. Obama’s presidency.
Nearly two months after Dylann Roof’s murderous swath through Mother Emanuel’s Wednesday night Bible study, the country is no longer as quick to discount the lethal power of racial hatred.
Snuggled in the humid cradle of what was once the Confederacy, Mother Emanuel exudes an air of radical reconciliation.
I had no desire to go to the basement to see where the shooting took place, but I could tell from looking into the faces of the racially mixed congregants as they left church Sunday morning that I had been standing on holy ground.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.