I’ve been thinking a lot lately about Sandra Bland, the Texas motorist who was arrested by a state trooper and held for days after changing lanes without signaling.
The dashcam footage of their fateful encounter shows an irritated Ms. Bland interacting with equally irritated Texas trooper Brian Encinia. What should have been a routine ticketing on Trooper Encinia’s part escalated into an exchange of angry words after he returned her registration and license to her.
When Ms. Bland refused to put out the cigarette she was smoking in her own car, Trooper Encinia ordered her out of the vehicle. Ms. Bland initially refused, then complied when he threatened to “light her up” with a Taser.
Seconds later, after they were out of dashcam range, Trooper Encinia apparently threw Ms. Bland, who was neither intoxicated nor armed, to the ground. She was handcuffed and taken to jail.
On the third day of her incarceration for failing to signal while changing lanes and for resisting arrest by allegedly kicking Trooper Encinia, Ms. Bland was found dead in her jail cell. The official story is that she took her own life by somehow using a plastic garbage bag to hang herself.
I have my doubts about every aspect of this story. The fact is that the trooper arrested Ms. Bland because he was upset that she defied him, ever so briefly.
There was no smell of marijuana in the car. She was not harboring illegal aliens or hauling suspicious packages. He could very easily have let her go after giving her a ticket, but he needed a pretext to arrest her. He wasn’t interested in de-escalating the conflict.
On her part, Ms. Bland didn’t bother to disguise her contempt for the arbitrary nature of the stop. She knew that an African-American woman was being subjected to implicit racial bias even if the white state trooper wouldn’t acknowledge it.
She could hear his disrespect for her rights as both a black woman and an ordinary citizen who refused to acquiesce to an insecure cop — one who was determined to assert his legal authority at the expense of any real moral authority.
Trooper Encinia had the advantage. He knew the U.S. Supreme Court would sanction his every move. Cops are given breathtaking latitude to make arrests. Like most citizens, Ms. Bland had only the vaguest notion of what her rights were during a police stop.
Her ignorance of the law would be used against her by a vindictive trooper who was willing to turn a routine traffic stop into a financial hole that would keep her in jail indefinitely. Ms. Bland’s bond was $5,000 — money she didn’t have, making the length of her stay as a guest of the state indefinite.
Had Ms. Bland been more acquiescent during the traffic stop — more apologetic, passive and, let’s be real, white — she presumably would still be alive today. But ordinary citizens are expected to cower in the presence of police authority or risk arrest — or worse.
Even by the most authoritarian-friendly interpretation of the law, what happened to Sandra Bland was not “justice,” though it was legal. Such willful oppression of ordinary citizens of all colors is practiced with impunity every day in every state by insecure men and women who are grateful for the public’s indifference. This is intolerable and shouldn’t happen in a democratic society.
I have no idea whether Ms. Bland killed herself in a fit of despair, as the authorities insist, or was hanged by hands unknown for reasons unknown, but she didn’t deserve to be in that jail cell in the first place.
A whole genre of videos on YouTube show ordinary citizens in tense encounters with police and with immigration officials manning checkpoints miles inside the United States. The videos usually feature young, articulate men, frequently white but also a few Hispanics. They calmly assert their rights as American citizens to drive unmolested and without fear of unlawful search and seizure by police.
After a few minutes of hostile cross-talk, the drivers are usually sent on their way by officers too spooked to mess with folks capable of citing the Constitution before the cuffs come out.
It probably isn’t something that everyone can get away with, but it does demonstrate the value of knowing one’s rights. At least a few citizens are doing their part to reclaim some measure of dignity in this democracy. That’s a start.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.