Bill Cosby will turn 78 on Sunday. If he’s even in the mood for what would surely be his most awkward birthday party ever, it will be attended by those who have no interest in believing that “America’s dad” is a sexual predator.
Because of the primacy within families of loyalty over logic, Mr. Cosby’s wife and daughters aren’t obligated to believe their patriarch’s own admission in a 2005 deposition that he obtained quaaludes to give them to unsuspecting women as a prelude to sex.
Oh, he’s been a less than faithful husband to his long-suffering wife, his relatives would concede, but the ordinary catting around of a mega-celebrity with female groupies doesn’t make him a serial rapist. The truth, they probably tell themselves, is more benign and less felonious than what they insist is a smear job in the media.
Bill Cosby and the more than three dozen women who have accused him of sexual assault over 40 years understand that the comedian’s great wealth has insulated him from legal jeopardy, but not from the court of public opinion. He knows that his days as a comedian, commercial pitchman and moral arbiter of anything are over.
“The stark contrast between Bill Cosby, the public moralist, and Bill Cosby, the subject of serious allegations concerning improper (and perhaps criminal) conduct, is a matter to which the [Associated Press] — and by extension the public — has a significant interest,” U.S. District Judge Eduardo Robreno of Philadelphia ruled this week when he unsealed the 2005 deposition.
Singer and Philly native Jill Scott, arguably Mr. Cosby’s fiercest defender on Twitter, threw in the towel after reading the deposition. She acknowledged she no longer believes her former mentor.
That leaves “The View” panelist Whoopi Goldberg as the most prominent Cosby “truther” out there. Ms. Goldberg insists that because he hasn’t actually been charged and convicted, Mr. Cosby deserves the presumption of innocence.
Technically, she’s right, but it isn’t a standard she’s willing to extend to, say, George Zimmerman. She weighed in with her opinion of his guilt even after he was exonerated at trial for killing Trayvon Martin. Consequently, her defense of Mr. Cosby’s right not to be tried in the court of public opinion feels tribal and irrational.
There have been columns and essays in recent days bemoaning Mr. Cosby’s fall from grace and whether it is somehow a unique burden for African-Americans. The theory goes that for all of the stern and hypocritical moralism he aimed at black people, Mr. Cosby was still the closest thing to a father many of them ever had. Thus, some believe that losing his symbolic value hurts.
The problem with this essentially racist argument is that Mr. Cosby was far more popular and influential with whites than younger blacks even before he excoriated the black underclass in his infamous “Pound Cake” speech in 2004. I have yet to see an essay or column about how Mr. Cosby’s current travails represent a unique burden for his white fans.
In a series of bold comic strips in 2005, Aaron McGruder, the African-American creator of “The Boondocks,” mocked Mr. Cosby for “doping and groping” former Temple University employee Andrea Constand. It was telling that Mr. Cosby didn’t even threaten to sue Mr. McGruder.
Fast forward to a blistering 2014 performance by 31-year-old comedian Hannibal Buress that reignited interest in the allegations against Mr. Cosby. In a bit that immediately went viral, Mr. Buress accused the elderly comedian of being a serial rapist.
Oddly enough, it didn’t generate any legal threats from Mr. Cosby’s lawyers. Mr. Buress’ standing in the African-American community remains solid. Thanks to O.J. Simpson, a whole generation of African-Americans is less willing to give uncritical support anymore to black celebrities, especially those famous for mocking them.
It’s no coincidence that just as Whoopi Goldberg maintains public faith in Mr. Cosby’s innocence, she can’t admit that O.J. is probably guilty of a double homicide, even though most other blacks view that differently from two decades ago.
This kind of willful blindness about black celebrities is more a “Whoopi thing” than a black thing, I’m happy to say.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.