It must have been exhausting for Rachel Dolezal to keep the story going as long as she did. The Spokane, Wash., NAACP president stepped down Monday after losing credibility from reports that she misrepresented her ethnicity for at least a decade.

Ms. Dolezal, who self-identifies as African-American, was born 37 years ago to Lawrence and Ruthanne Dolezal. Both parents self-identify as white. You don’t have to be a Cambridge-trained logician to figure out what that makes Rachel, if what they say is true.

To bolster the contention that their daughter has no more right to identify herself as African-American than they do, the Dolezals released photos to the media of a young Rachel that showed only Tilda Swinton and Nicole Kidman were whiter than she was when she was a teenager.

The Dolezals were never interested in debating the “fluidity of race” in America or whether a “trans-racial” identity is legitimate or not. They cut through all the sociological mumbo-jumbo with pictures of a blond-haired girl with freckles, an image that brought an automatic presumption of privilege if she had chosen to claim it.

Advertise with us

In doing so, the Dolezals upended their estranged daughter’s very complicated life and the lies that buttressed it. Still, the public is no closer to understanding what Rachel Dolezal’s reasons were for appropriating the look and back story that comes with being a black woman.

The armchair psychoanalysis that accompanies every twist in this story speaks to the continuing discomfort most Americans have with race. The majority of those commenting on Ms. Dolezal’s deception are most comfortable with the fixed racial categories that have been the status quo in America for hundreds of years.

Everyone knows that whatever “white” means as a fixed racial category in the American imagination, it is a racial ideal that has already been adulterated by “non-whites” who managed to be indistinguishable from the melanin-deprived natives after crossing over the racial divide to snatch some privilege.

Although they may not like it, the folks who subscribe to white privilege understand intellectually why a black person might want to pass for white. What they can’t quite get their heads around is why someone like Rachel Dolezal would give up her privileged status as a white American woman to become a black academic and activist unless she were absolutely crazy.

A lot of the snark on social media and the commentary on cable news are from people whose understanding of race is very regimented. They can’t imagine what could possibly be gained by being black. It doesn’t help that Ms. Dolezal has said ridiculous things about her upbringing that stretch the concept of American self-invention to absurd lengths.

Advertise with us

The contempt being directed at this woman for daring to be an ally of black people — albeit a dishonest one, based on how she represented herself — is breathtaking. While I’m not condoning her lies and misrepresentations, I’m happy to commend her for the good she’s done and for the good I hope she’s able to continue doing once the smoke clears.

Until she’s ready to talk about why she did what she did in a thoughtful and non-defensive way, I think it’s safe to assume that part of what we’re witnessing here is essentially a family drama as awkward and alienating as anything we’ve seen from William Faulkner or Toni Morrison or Tennessee Williams.

Rachel Dolezal was raised in a home where her white parents adopted three African-American children and one child from Haiti. She learned racial tolerance from her parents and was encouraged to identify with the black experience early on, starting with her siblings.

Still, something put Ms. Dolezal on a different track from her family to the point where she felt compelled to break off regular contact with her parents. This led to their willingness to spill the beans about their daughter’s deception despite the embarrassment and disruption to all of their lives.

But this is America — a land where we continue to be in denial about our racial history and how it affects us. Still, we seize every opportunity we can to talk about it, though it is obvious that we prefer that the conversation be filtered through a very strange and very indirect discourse. Ms. Dolezal’s unnecessary 10-year lie is proof of that.