In a much-quoted tweet last week, actress Gabrielle Union expressed shock that Theodor “Dr. Seuss” Geisel had once drawn black people in ways that didn’t reflect the civil rights era enlightenment of “The Sneetches.”
“Nooooooo!!! Not Dr. Seuss?!?!” Ms. Union tweeted in response to a racist drawing Dr. Seuss did for Judge magazine in 1929. “Childhood retroactively blown,” Ms. Union said of the drawing that was recently unearthed and put up for auction with a minimum $20,000 bid. Despite Dr. Seuss’ fame, it failed to garner a single bid.
These days, it would be difficult for all but the most unrepentant racist to look at a drawing that featured nearly two dozen big-lipped stereotypes standing placidly next to a sign that read: “Take home a high-grade [racial epithet] for your woodpile. Satisfaction guaranteed.”
Unlike Ms. Union, my childhood was not retroactively blown by news that the Dr. Seuss who created “Horton Hears a Who,” “Green Eggs and Ham,” “The Cat in the Hat” and other beloved childhood classics had not always been the liberal Democrat of his later years.
It was well-known that Dr. Seuss was an eager American propagandist during World War II who depicted Japanese civilians and soldiers as buck-toothed grotesqueries, though Hitler and his German high command got some of that treatment, too.
Still, it is a drag to realize that as late as the mid-1940s, Dr. Seuss and other cartoonists including the great Will Eisner (“The Spirit”) and the animators at Disney were still portraying blacks as buffoons, though not quite the subhumans of earlier decades.
Scores of Bugs Bunny and Tom and Jerry cartoons are now permanently exiled from the cartoon canon because of racist depictions of blacks, Hispanics, Jews and Asians, although most Americans didn’t consider them offensive at the time.
It is hard to believe that there is a generation of Americans who aren’t aware that Tom and Jerry both occupied a house that was owned by a black woman who was depicted as so large she couldn’t fit on the screen, so we were given only glimpses of her bosom, ample behind and big feet. We could see the shadow of the kerchief around her head sometimes.
Warner Bros., the studio that brought us Bugs Bunny, the Road Runner, Daffy Duck and Porky Pig, was especially fast and loose with its depiction of racial stereotypes. If you can sit through a Speedy Gonzales cartoon without your eyes popping out of your head, you’re simply an insensitive lout.
Many of these cartoons were still being rerun on Saturday mornings in the late 1960s, so they were literally a part of my childhood. Even so, I don’t consider my childhood retroactively blown as the result of watching them. They were often ferociously clever and incredibly funny.
Fortunately, the civil rights movement was actively confronting America about its conscious and unconscious biases. As the tent poles that supported Jim Crow began to wobble and finally fall, folks like Dr. Seuss saw the error of their ways and repented.
By the time I was 10 years old, I had already internalized the message in Dr. Seuss’ brilliant parable about tolerance featuring the plain-bellied Sneetches and the star-bellied Sneetches.
Dr. Seuss’ greatest children’s story summed up the absurdity of American racial exceptionalism perfectly. Everyone who read that tale of tolerance and inclusivity or had it read to them by a parent knew it was challenging the ways we Americans typically looked at the world. It was the perfect counter to the tsunami of offensive narratives that most of us took for granted.
That’s why the late Theodor Geisel will always get a pass in my book. Whatever racially offensive images he put into the world between the Depression and World War II, he more than made up for with a rich catalog of children’s books that espoused the opposite philosophy a few decades later.
As beloved as Dr. Seuss and his work are, it is also heartening that no one bid on a racist drawing that fails to represent his idealism and is the opposite of what made him one of the most indispensable storytellers of the 20th century.
Someone should tell Gabrielle Union that she shouldn’t consider her childhood retroactively blown because Dr. Seuss had a racist past. If America is ever to have a future that reflects our best ideas and values, Dr. Seuss will be a big part of it.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.