Because the First Amendment is guaranteed to generate strange bedfellows during the best of times, one doesn’t always get a say about who occupies the empty spot on the dirty mattress next to you.
These days, many progressives are feeling queasy about exchanging bed bugs with noted Islamophobe Pamela Geller, the shrill provocateur who arranged the “Jihad Watch Muhammad Art Exhibit and Cartoon Contest” in Garland, Texas, last weekend.
Two American-born Islamic extremists who tried to crash the party were stopped before they even left the parking lot by a cop who was a lot handier with his pistol than they were with their automatic weapons. Blood was spilled that Sunday afternoon, but it was their blood and not the blood of the “infidels” who mingled inside the community center unaware of the drama outside.
In the days that followed, Ms. Geller tried to rebrand herself as a free speech cause celebre, which was hilarious given the anti-free speech tenor of her campaign to prevent a mosque from being built near Ground Zero a few years ago. At that time, Ms. Geller cloaked her bigotry in an abundance of concern for Americans who would be reminded of the trauma of 9/11 every time they heard the Muslim call to prayer coming from the mosque.
But instead of being celebrated as a glamorous hybrid of Salman Rushdie and “American Sniper,” Ms. Geller’s willingness to court a possible bloodbath on American soil was called out by Fox News hosts Bill O’Reilly, Greta Van Susteren and Martha MacCallum; radio talk show host Laura Ingraham; Catholic League president Bill Donohue; Donald Trump; and the Rev. Franklin Graham.
Predictably, Sean Hannity and the lesser lights of the “The Five” were solidly in Ms. Geller’s corner. They would have us believe, like their conspiracy theorist hero, that Shariah law is only days away from being imposed on the United States.
Megyn Kelly, who is arguably Fox’s biggest and most sensible star, made an impassioned defense of Ms. Geller’s right to be an obnoxious jerk on First Amendment grounds, even if her drawing contest offended the sensibilities of a billion Muslims.
Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck and the majority of notable conservative talk radio hosts and bloggers applauded the conspiracy theorist and denounced her conservative critics. It would be amusing to watch this civil war unfurl if a version of this fight weren’t also happening among my ideological brethren on the left.
This week, the editors of Charlie Hebdo — the satirical French magazine that features cartoons regularly lampooning Muhammad, Jesus and every sacred cow imaginable — were honored with the PEN American Center’s Freedom of Expression Courage Award.
Eight Charlie Hebdo staffers, most of them cartoonists, were murdered in January by Islamic militants avenging what they considered the magazine’s routine insult of Muhammad. PEN’s decision to give Charlie Hebdo one of its highest awards was controversial among the ranks of American writers who view the magazine’s “satire” as oppressing religious minorities.
A petition signed by 145 literary luminaries — including Francine Prose, Lorrie Moore, Junot Diaz and Joyce Carol Oates — objected strenuously to awarding Charlie Hebdo anything. “Doonesbury” creator Garry Trudeau, no stranger to cartoon satire himself, gave a speech last month ridiculing the notion that Charlie Hebdo was part of the grand tradition of comforting the afflicted and afflicting the comfortable.
These writers and artists are my people. Their opinions mean a lot to me, but in this case they’re wrong. Charlie Hebdo isn’t a particularly funny or enlightening magazine from what I can tell, but it has a place in the French imagination I’m not prepared to second-guess. Its staff’s sacrifice this year should be recognized.
The cartoons in Charlie Hebdo that cause so much offense also offend me as a Christian, but so what? I’m more offended by the notion that words and images can be vetoed by bullets or censorship.
Still, a vigorous debate about the meaning of the First Amendment can only be a good thing, especially when it transcends the usual political polarities. You don’t have to agree with Pam Geller’s odious politics to defend her right to be a creepy bigot and publicity monger.
“Je suis Pam Geller?” Every now and then the First Amendment compels us to sleep with the enemy.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.