Maybe Pittsburgh walks around with a giant “Kick me” sign on its back. How else does one account for the region’s national reputation as a place to pass counterfeit money with minimal chance of getting pinched?

The theory happens not to be true, by the way. Criminal syndicates from New York, in particular, may have us pegged as hayseeds whose eyeballs pop out of our skulls at the sight of $100 bills, but they still end up getting caught more often than not.

This is the rare occasion where our regional disposition to make strangers carrying big bills earn our trust works to our advantage. If some hipsters from Brooklyn blow into town and try to buy, say, a $5 mustache corkscrew bottle opener from a merchant in Lawrenceville using a $100 bill printed in North Korea, they’re not going to get $95 in change. Instead, they’re probably going to get busted.

Merchants in this town have no compunction about putting your money through its paces before sticking it into the cash register drawer. There’s no social embarrassment on a cashier’s part when it comes to eyeballing $20, $50 and $100 bills like they were hanging chads on a Florida voting ballot.

Advertise with us

Ever notice how the Whole Foods cashiers deal with big denominations? As polite as they usually are, they aren’t about to get stuck with monopoly money on their shift. Even the most solicitous clerk puts his guard up the second you produce a big wad of cash to pay for a couple bucks worth of groceries.

Without exception, every big bill is held up to the light for full spectrum analysis. The cashiers will even give you the once over if it helps them to determine whether your money is kosher. The assumption is that until a close inspection of the legal tender proves otherwise, you’re a counterfeiter — and not a particularly smart one.

I used to resent it, but not anymore. Back in the ‘90s, I wrote a column complaining about merchants racially profiling the $20 bills I gave them, but even my most paranoid black readers said I was being silly. It turns out, they were right.

Whether you’re at Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, Target, Giant Eagle, McDonald’s or Walmart, large denomination paper money is going to be closely inspected regardless of who you are and what you look like. I’ve noticed that a lot of regional gas stations have stopped accepting any paper currency over $20. That makes a lot of sense to me.

If Pittsburgh has developed a reputation as a place to drop funny money, it isn’t because of store merchants or fast food clerks. While the Secret Service and the U.S. attorney’s office take it seriously, not all of the local judges who hear these cases agree that sending a counterfeiter to prison is the way to go.

Advertise with us

Case in point: U.S. District Judge Mark Hornak just slapped the wrist of Marcus Taylor, 31, a New Yorker convicted of passing counterfeit bills here. The judge imposed 60 months’ probation and no jail time on a guy who conspired with two others to distribute $4,000 in bogus bills in the region.

Taylor blamed society and an upbringing full of deprivation for his conduct, a notion justifiably mocked by federal prosecutors. Who knows if such a transparently goofy argument swayed Judge Hornak to go easy on Taylor.

All we know for sure is that Taylor, who was prosecuted for murder when he was a wee lad of 16, gets to go back to Brooklyn to brag about how he “got one over on the rubes in Pittsburgh.”

Will a toothless punishment for passing fake Benjamins encourage other out-of-town criminals and counterfeiters to try their luck here? I don’t see why not. As vigilant as most retailers and shop clerks are, the odds are that some businesses will succumb to fraud and hand over hard-earned cash to one of these crooks.

The U.S. attorney’s office has six more counterfeiting cases that it is prosecuting locally. Four defendants are from New York, one is from Chicago and one is from West Virginia. Unless they’re lucky enough to be assigned to Judge Hornak, they’re probably going to get serious time in a squalid prison if convicted.

Meanwhile, I look forward to having my money seriously inspected and eyeballed by the next clerk or cashier to whom I hand a $20 bill. Honest, I get it now. No one should take any wooden nickels if they can avoid it.