In the Nov. 9, 1967, issue of a weird new fanzine he dubbed Rolling Stone, college dropout Jann Wenner wrote, “You’re probably wondering what we’re trying to do.”
“It’s hard to say: sort of a magazine and sort of a newspaper,” he continued. “The name of it is Rolling Stone which comes from an old saying, ‘A rolling stone gathers no moss.’ Muddy Waters used the name for a song he wrote. The Rolling Stones took their name from Muddy’s song. ‘Like a Rolling Stone’ was the title of Bob Dylan’s first rock and roll record. We have begun a new publication reflecting what we see are the changes related to rock and roll.”
When Mr. Wenner founded Rolling Stone nearly a half-century ago, he envisioned it as a place where fans of popular music like himself could write incisively, if not always critically, about the music and culture of the times.
At Rolling Stone, journalism informed by the values and attitudes of the counterculture came into its own. Fan-boyish articles about the symbolism of Bob Dylan’s lyrics and Led Zeppelin’s pretentiousness eventually gave way to hallucinogenic takes on America by Hunter S. Thompson during the Nixon presidency.
It was at Rolling Stone where novelist Tom Wolfe chose to serialize an early version of “Bonfire of the Vanities,” a savage evisceration of the rapacious capitalism and pathos of New York City in the mid-1980s.
Some of the best reporting on the 2008 financial crisis was done in the magazine’s pages by Matt Taibbi, who coined the term “a great vampire squid” to refer to Goldman Sachs and other many-tentacled financial institutions.
While Rolling Stone shifted its emphasis from music to general entertainment, its hard-news division continued to produce remarkably consistent and solidly sourced reportage over the decades. Important stories on criminal justice, the environment, education and the absurdity of modern American political theater became staples of its coverage, even as its music criticism and reporting declined in quality.
Before a disastrous University of Virginia rape story published in November called the magazine’s journalism into question, Rolling Stone last made waves with “The Runaway General,” a 2010 story by the late Michael Hastings about Gen. Stanley McChrystal. It quoted him mocking his civilian commanders, including Vice President Joe Biden.
That story led to Gen. McChrystal’s ouster as military commander in Afghanistan within a week of publication. Not one word of it has ever been repudiated, though some have criticized Mr. Hastings for reporting what Gen. McChrystal and his staff “assumed” were off-the-record comments.
Then came the much-discredited article by staff writer Sabrina Rubin Erdely about a gang rape at a University of Virginia frat house. The fraternity, Phi Kappa Psi, strenuously denied the allegations made in the story by a student identified only as “Jackie.”
After The Washington Post punched holes in the story and after an extensive investigation by law enforcement turned up nothing to support the alleged crime, Ms. Erdely’s story fell apart.
Invited by Rolling Stone to explore the journalistic missteps involved, the Columbia Journalism School just released its own postmortem, and it is devastating. It indicts Ms. Erdely, her editors, the magazine’s fact-checkers and the confirmation bias that made those in charge reluctant to challenge the alleged rape victim’s glaring inconsistencies.
Still, Mr. Wenner, a man who has published exposes on other institutions and individuals for decades, refuses to punish anyone at his magazine for one of the most egregious journalistic screw-ups in recent memory.
It did not take long for this statement from the aggrieved fraternity at the center of the UVA controversy to make the rounds: “After 130 days of living under a cloud of suspicion as a result of reckless reporting by Rolling Stone magazine, today the Virginia Alpha Chapter of Phi Kappa Psi announced plans to pursue all available legal action against the magazine.”
Many members of the media will be cheering “the bros” of Phi Kappa Psi as they attempt to take Rolling Stone to the cleaners for undermining its own history of fine investigative journalism by failing to hold its own journalists accountable.
To paraphrase the Grateful Dead, it’s been a long, strange trip to hackdom for Rolling Stone magazine, but it finally got there.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.