What does it say about us when we’re relieved that the two cops shot and wounded in Ferguson last week were just collateral damage and not the shooter’s intended target?

Assuming that shooting suspect Jeffrey L. Williams is convicted, his reported explanation that he was actually targeting civilians he’d argued with earlier that evening isn’t going to generate much sympathy with cops or protesters.

We only have the police version of Mr. Williams’ statement, but it makes it sound like he understands he’s in a lot of trouble but thinks “clarifying” his intentions will somehow mitigate the damage.

In a perverse way, Mr. Williams would be correct. In the hierarchy of street violence, the shooting of two police officers, either on purpose or by accident, generates far more anxiety on the public’s part than when two civilians are injured.

Advertise with us

Targeting police is interpreted as a literal attack on society, the system and our way of life. Targeting black people is considered business as usual. The black people dutifully filling morgue gurneys are the collateral damage that result from the intersection of unregistered guns, poverty, nihilism, the drug war and societal indifference.

Despite the “Black lives matter” chant heard from Ferguson to Cleveland to New York City, those most responsible for ending black lives do so with the conviction that black lives only truly matter when a cop is the designated executioner that day.

Based on the statement released by police, Mr. Williams is one of those people for whom black lives matter least. His willingness to take credit for the double shooting in Ferguson last week, but only after making clear that he intended to shoot someone else, would be funny if it weren’t evidence of his moral obtuseness.

Mr. Williams is part of a long tradition of black people who don’t like other black people enough to respect their right to live. For them, “Black lives matter” is just a slogan to be chanted in the presence of nervous cops and television cameras. It isn’t something to be taken seriously by someone who takes a gun to a protest rally.

Fortunately, those who do take the chant seriously were in a position to help police with tips and information leading to Mr. Williams’ arrest, despite a prominent law enforcement official’s ignorant charges that they had gotten what they wanted with the shooting of the two police officers. Being true to their values also meant being responsible citizens by cooperating with the police in their search for the shooter.

Advertise with us

Still, the protesters maintained their right to oppose the systematic discrimination and oppression in Ferguson unveiled in the Justice Department’s report on last year’s Michael Brown shooting. Mr. Williams’ actions temporarily put the protesters in a bad light, but they refused to succumb to calls to “respect” the wounded officers by abandoning their protests.

While some in the media and law enforcement glibly suggested that the shooting was the logical outcome of non-violent protest against police, anyone with a brain knew that shooting cops isn’t something that would ever be sanctioned by protesters.

With Mr. Williams’ arrest, his stated motives matter far more than all the theories about what happened that night. Still, no one can take comfort in his callous disregard for another human being’s right not to be shot for the pettiest of reasons.

There are critics of the protesters who would have preferred if it were revealed that the cops had been targeted. That way their call for the end of protests in the name of public safety would’ve gained some traction.

Others express the bizarre opinion that Mr. Williams is somehow being set up. These conspiracy theorists wonder why the suspect was arrested within days with a gun linked to the crime. How often does that happen in real life? How could anyone stupidly hold on to so much incriminating evidence after a shooting? The assumption is that criminals have common sense. They don’t. In fact, most criminals are willfully stupid.

Advertise with us

Had Mr. Williams shot two “ordinary” black people in any other city in the country that evening, he may very well have gotten away with it, as there would have been less intensity to solve the crime.

Still, it is gratifying that tips provided by the protesters and the public helped catch someone who may have so little regard for either the cops or black lives. If only this were the pattern for solving every shooting in America. Black lives matter only if we take our responsibility seriously enough to call a police tip line.