Announcing a moratorium on Pennsylvania’s use of the death penalty a week ago, newly elected Gov. Tom Wolf charitably described the capital punishment system as “error prone, expensive and anything but infallible.”
Mr. Wolf didn’t abolish the death penalty in Pennsylvania, but he went further than his predecessors by echoing what governors across the nation from both parties have said in recent years — their states don’t operate in good faith when it comes to executing prisoners.
“If we are to continue to administer the death penalty, we must take further steps to ensure that defendants have appropriate counsel at every stage of their prosecution, that the sentence is applied fairly and proportionally, and that we eliminate the risk of executing an innocent,” Mr. Wolf said.
Given how underfunded public defender offices are across the state, this seems reasonable. To say that politically minded district attorneys in the hinterlands and in our state’s largest cities might tolerate some glaring injustices because of public opinion, police pressure or political expedience is also obvious.
Mr. Wolf imposed the moratorium because he wants the task force on capital punishment created four years ago by the state Senate to finally deliver a report that was due on ex-Gov. Tom Corbett’s desk in December 2013.
Unless you’re invested in the way things are done, regardless of how much justice it delivers, there’s nothing wrong with having more facts about a system that imposes irrevocable punishment. This is where Philadelphia District Attorney Seth Williams enters the picture.
Mr. Williams, a Democrat, accused Mr. Wolf of acting like a “despot.” The prosecutor petitioned the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to overturn the moratorium on the grounds that the governor has exceeded his authority.
“Our constitution does not allow the governor to satisfy his own personal opinions by halting a capital murderer’s sentence that was authorized by state statute, imposed by a unanimous Philadelphia jury, and upheld by state and federal courts,” Mr. Williams said.
He also used the term “lawless” and accused Mr. Wolf of usurpation and violating “his duty to faithfully execute Pennsylvania law.” After hearing him lay it on that thick, one has to ask why Mr. Williams doesn’t issue a warrant for the governor’s arrest or move for an indictment, assuming he believes his own rhetoric. But it’s clear that he doesn’t believe it and that he’s just show-boating.
Very few Pennsylvania politicians of either party ooze raw ambition quite as much as Mr. Williams. He’s doing everything he can to burnish his reputation as a non-partisan, law-and-order Democrat whom a rural Republican could vote for in good conscience should his name ever turn up on a statewide ballot.
It amounts to a silly kabuki dance on the Philly D.A.’s part, because Pennsylvania isn’t Texas and never will be. The last person executed in this state was North Philly cannibal /torturer Gary Heidnik, who was executed in 1999 for the murder and mutilation of two women he kept chained in his basement. Even those of us who oppose the death penalty in principle skipped that particular vigil.
There are currently 183 men and three women on Pennsylvania’s death row. Only three individuals have been executed in the commonwealth since the U.S. Supreme Court restored the death penalty in 1976. We’re not particularly bloodthirsty here, though juries aren’t shy about imposing death sentences when they know they won’t be carried out.
Because of the state’s cumbersome appeals process, a death row inmate has to give up the right to all appeals before an execution can go forward, anyway. That’s not likely to happen. That’s why someone on death row here is more likely to die of old age than be executed, no matter how notorious the crime.
All Mr. Wolf did was put a moratorium on the books that matches the reality on the ground in Pennsylvania. For this he is being called a “despot” by a fellow Democrat. I suspect Mr. Williams is about to find out what it's like to be on the political equivalent of the Wolf administration’s death row.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.