There’s something about Alabama that always brings out the worst in people wearing robes.
Take Alabama Chief Justice Roy Moore, who wears the black robe of that state’s highest court. Judge Moore is so determined to keep marriage reserved for heterosexuals that he announced he will defy the U.S. Supreme Court, if necessary.
That would put Judge Moore in the same company as those who have historically worn white robes in that state. Defying federal authority is what they do in Alabama.
Too bad that during a contentious interview Thursday, CNN anchor Chris Cuomo didn’t insist on Judge Moore’s opinion about the legality of Gov. George Wallace blocking the entrance to the University of Alabama to two black students in 1963, rather than comply with the federal order to admit them.
Gov. Wallace believed that federal judges had no right to interfere in how Alabama administered its state schools. His mantra while defying a U.S. Supreme Court decision and a federal order will live in infamy: “Segregation now. Segregation tomorrow. Segregation forever.”
Gov. Wallace backed down the next day when federal troops moved in. He nonetheless became a hero to the states’ rights crowd that believed his defiance, though short-lived, was a model for how Alabama should proceed through the rest of the 20th century and beyond — drag its feet, obfuscate and appeal to divine authority while ignoring federal mandates.
In fairness, Judge Moore was a 16-year-old high school student at the time Gov. Wallace made his stand, but I think it’s safe to assume that the Alabama chief justice has never been a maverick when it comes to the rights of minorities. What did he think of Gov. Wallace’s stance at the time? He’s too smart to tell us, but we can make a reasonably educated guess.
Siding with those who were pro-integration in 1963 would have made the teenage Roy Moore an outlier among white Alabamans with strong Christian convictions. Usually, those were the same folks who wore the white robes of intolerance at night or sympathized with those who did. Alabama, like Mississippi, was synonymous with domestic terror against civil rights workers and has always been among the slowest to embrace justice.
Judge Moore told Mr. Cuomo that if the U.S. Supreme Court rules in favor of same-sex marriage, he “will follow the law” as he interprets it, meaning that he will never order other state officials in Alabama to implement it.
“If it’s an unlawful mandate, you can refuse to mandate it,” he said. He compared a potential Supreme Court decision favoring gay marriage to Plessy v. Ferguson, the 1896 ruling that upheld the constitutionality of “separate but equal” facilities based on race, and the Dred Scott decision, the 1857 ruling that said one American could own another.
It is obvious by Judge Moore’s track record that he would have defended Plessy v. Ferguson and perhaps even Dred Scott v. Sandford with every fiber of his being had he been on the Alabama bench in the 1800s.
He isn’t fooling anyone by acting as if defying the Supreme Court over gay marriage would be the moral equivalent of taking a stand against the court’s unjust rulings in 1896 and 1857. It would be the reverse — a perpetuation of injustice.
There’s something perverse about Judge Moore claiming he’s appalled by the Supreme Court’s historic denigration of black people at the same time that he’s arguing for continued discrimination against another group, based solely on their sexual identity. That’s the kind of hypocrisy that should be called out.
I have no doubt that Judge Moore is sincere in his convictions, but that doesn’t make him worthy of wielding the power he does in a pluralistic society. There are Alabamans who don’t share his religious views but still look to him for some semblance of objectivity, especially when higher courts recognize legal rights for minorities he refuses to embrace.
Because Judge Moore is barring the door to gay marriage in Alabama the way Gov. Wallace tried to stop blacks from integrating a university two generations ago, only 23 of the state’s 67 counties are issuing marriage licenses to gay couples despite a federal judge’s order. That’s shameful and obstructionist.
How is that somehow morally superior to Plessy v. Ferguson or Dred Scott? Judge Moore is worse than Wallace, who publicly repented his bigotry before he died.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.