Count me among those genuinely excited by the news that author Harper Lee has sanctioned the publication of a novel she wrote before “To Kill a Mockingbird” became an instant classic in 1960.
On July 14, publisher HarperCollins will release “Go Set a Watchman,” a 304-page novel set in the 1950s during the civil rights struggle in Alabama. Taking place 20 years after the events in “Mockingbird,” it also features lawyer Atticus Finch and his now-grown daughter, Scout Finch.
Of course, a literary event of this magnitude wouldn’t be possible without some hint of controversy and intrigue. Much has been made of the fact that Ms. Lee, 88, has agreed to the publication of a second novel despite five decades of resisting all entreaties.
Due to the fact that Ms. Lee is a stroke survivor, legally blind, profoundly deaf and inclined to “sign anything set before her by people she trusts,” according to her late sister, Alice Lee, there’s suspicion about whether she’s been coerced.
Those of a conspiratorial bent believe it isn’t a coincidence that soon after the death of Alice, a lawyer who was her fiercest protector, a “deal” is announced to publish a book assumed lost or destroyed by the author decades ago. It resurfaced in a “secure location” containing her private papers.
The manuscript was discovered by Harper Lee’s lawyer, Tonja Carter, who couldn’t believe what she was reading. Still, it was a hard sell to get Ms. Lee to go along with publishing it after insisting for more than half a century that she’d said all she ever planned to say about Scout, Atticus and fictional Maycomb, Ala.
“After much thought and hesitation, I shared it with a handful of people I trust and was pleased to hear they considered it worthy of publication,” Ms. Lee said in a prepared statement released this week, one that her friends in Monroeville, Ala., say doesn’t sound like her.
The details of the HarperCollins deal aren’t public, but the publishing house is guaranteed to make Fort Knox-level money once “Go Set a Watchman” debuts in July. Ms. Lee will be well-compensated, but many in her hometown suspect she’s being exploited by her lawyer and HarperCollins, considering she had been so adamant about not publishing a second book.
They believe that if Alice Lee were still alive, she wouldn’t allow her younger sister to be maneuvered by an eager publishing house that knows it can make tens of millions in profit from a second Harper Lee novel, whether or not it holds its own against its predecessor.
Also lingering in the background is the suspicion fostered by Truman Capote, her childhood friend, neighbor and rival, that he shaped the narrative of “Mockingbird.” Even those who dismiss Capote’s claim allow for the possibility that the book’s first editor might have been the true guiding genius behind the book, which could “explain” why she never wrote a second novel (assuming she barely wrote the first).
With that original editor long dead or out of the picture, “Go Set a Watchman” might read like any first novelist’s submission — awkward and clunky. It will likely pale in comparison to one that was as rigorously edited as “Mockingbird.”
Many of Ms. Lee’s admirers have a visceral fear of being disappointed by her second novel, as if her literary reputation deserved to remain too big to fail. If anything, they wish “Watchman” was being released posthumously, so that Harper Lee could escape the indignity of reading negative reviews in our contrarian, troll-driven literary environment.
But if we’re reasonable about this, we can learn as much from any failure by Ms. Lee as we have from her Pulitzer Prize-winning success. Reading the unedited version of her “first” novel will be a pleasure for anyone who admires what she’s already given us. She’s earned the right to fail, given the indelibly rich characters she gave birth to 55 years ago.
That’s why a lot of the sturm und drang surrounding the announcement feels like it is beside the point. No one questions whether Harper Lee wrote the book, but there is suspicion about the timing of its release. Me? I’m comfortable with ambiguity, since I anticipate it will be a fine read.
I can’t wait to see who plays Atticus and Scout once they start shooting the inevitable movie. Sam Waterston was born to play an older Atticus, and Natalie Portman would make a great Scout Finch. You read it here first.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.