Antisemitism in the United States is now so flagrant that the House of Representatives can barely summon a majority to rebuke a member for espousing the erasure of Israel from the planet.
They did manage it, however, censuring Rep. Rashida Tlaib yesterday for using the genocidal slogan “From the river to the sea” (including in a video she posted). But her fellow progressives — including Pittsburgh’s Summer Lee — felt free to offer their consolation and solidarity.
After the antisemitic fomenting by the extreme right during the Trump years, it is now exploding on the political left. And, judging from news accounts and social media posts, in far greater numbers and with more brazen immorality.
Embraced by the young
Outside Congress, this antisemitism is especially concentrated among the young, expressed in street protests and on formerly respectable college campuses. Jewish students feel increasingly unsafe, as students who oppose Israel’s response to Hamas terrorism blame them for it simply because they’re Jewish.
Where did this hatred come from? And how do we respond to people, young or old, who are so morally unmoored?
Read More
In our society, young people begin the task of defining themselves by defying authority and embracing the cause of others they view as oppressed by that same authority. To some extent, then, today’s young are like those who have come before, at least since the baby boomers.
But to some extent, young American protestors are the victims of years of woefully inadequate education and history-free reporting. They are largely unaware of the singular narrative of the Jews, a people-group persecuted like none other in human history.
Too many are unaware of the centuries of pogroms that preceded the Holocaust. They do not know that the Jews’ claim to the land of Israel predates the Palestinians’ by almost three millennia. They have not studied the Arab-Israeli war of 1948, at Israel’s founding, nor the wars since (all launched by Israel’s Muslim neighbors). And so on.
Instead, progressives — young and old — interpret the Middle East through the parochial lens of American culture, with ancient tribes who are all Semites assigned roles, irrationally, that conform to our tragic black-white racism. “Zionism is White Supremacy”? What ignorance.
The Middle East is not the United States. Simplistic thinking will not bring justice to either the Jews or the Palestinians.
To be pitied and feared
Many generations of American young people have stretched their wings and found their voices without embracing murder. The unimaginable — but verified — barbarism of the Hamas terrorists’ massacre should have shaken all humans to their core. It should have ignited serious soul-searching and political realignments.
Some, instead, celebrated the carnage. They are to be pitied — and feared.
As an antidote to such inhumanity I encourage you to explore the heartening testimonials of people who “woke up on Oct. 7 as progressives and went to bed that night feeling like conservatives.” That’s a quote from just one such essay at The Free Press.
The Free Press is the online news organization founded by Pittsburgh native Bari Weiss, a voluntary exile from the progressive corruption of The New York Times. Given the fearless reporting and editorializing at thefp.com, Ms. Weiss reminds me of the Bible’s Esther, raised up “for such a time as this.”
We don’t have to agree with every decision made by the Israeli government. We can and should question its excesses or short-sightedness in handling the threats that surround it. We should keep a wary eye on the possibility of the war’s expansion. We should hold the nation to its own highest standards in its treatment of the citizens of Gaza and the West Bank.
The Middle East situation is so complex that it’s impossible to address fully in this or any small space, but there are some truths that are indeed clear, if not simple:
Zionism — the right of the Jews to self-determination and to their historic homeland — is good and just. The decision by the victorious Allies to support it in the wake of the Holocaust and centuries of pogroms was correct.
The displaced Palestinians should embrace a two-state solution, reject control by barbaric terrorists and instead support their own legitimate government.
The Jews have the right to respond with overwhelming force to Hamas, an enemy dedicated, by its very charter, to wiping them off the face of the earth.
Responding to evil
More Palestinians than Jews have died in this new war but this is, morally speaking, far more the fault of Hamas than of Israel. Hamas initiated this war and uses innocent Palestinians as both bait and shields.
We can support Israel and criticize it — “faithful are the wounds of a friend,” as the ancient proverb says — but we must not tolerate the “F—k Jews” and “Kill Jews” slogans bawled and scrawled anywhere. People devoted to liberty and free speech should use theirs to respond to such evil.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “In the county executive race, it's ambition vs. experience.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.