Today marks the 100th anniversary of Armistice Day, the truce that ended the disastrous and senseless First World War.
Numerous new books mark this centennial. A recent overview of them in the New Yorker whets the appetite to learn more, but the article itself — by Adam Hochschild, author of 2011’s “To End All Wars: A Story of Loyalty and Rebellion, 1914-1918” — contained plenty of thought-provoking details.
Perhaps because I was reading Mr. Hochschild’s words in the days just after the pipe-bomb crisis and the Tree of Life massacre, certain century-old facts took on a deeper resonance. The strangest and most ominous to me was that in the weeks leading up to the armistice, German citizens had no idea their nation’s defeat was at hand.
“Their ignorance was a fateful result of unrelenting propaganda,” Mr. Hochschild writes.
“The German military controlled press censorship, keeping all word of mass desertions, for instance, out of the papers. As the tide turned against Germany, [domestic news] fully parted ways with reality, remaining relentlessly triumphal to the last. The apparent German retreat? A mere temporary setback. Even a few weeks before the armistice, the country’s newspapers were still running stories about an imminent final victory.”
The harsh terms of the armistice included massive reparations and continued war-like blockades that caused widespread hunger and starvation. This drastic shift from expected victory to crushing defeat sowed a sense of betrayal and national humiliation. The harvest was the even more catastrophic Second World War.
Obviously, many events contributed to that great horror, but a groundwork of resentment and suffering was laid when Germany’s domestic press, controlled by the military, “fully parted ways with reality.”
Today, as cries of “fake news” and “propaganda” regularly ring out, the need for trustworthy, impartial coverage of current events has never been greater, or more elusive.
America can cherish its history of a free, vigorous press. Moreover, today’s countless information sources make it very difficult, if not impossible, for any single entity like the military or the White House to control news the way the kaiser’s Germany or Stalin’s Russia did.
That, however, does not mean we are not endangered by false narratives. We are. The current climate is a war of its own — a war of competing narratives. Its victims are not dead but they are maimed, and so is our democratic enterprise.
It does not help the nation to have a president who declares the press to be “the enemy of the people.” It also does not help to have news media whose coverage of the president is 90 percent negative, no matter what he says or does.
It is good to have reporters point out when any politician is wrong; it is not good when reporters make no distinction between error and willful lying, nor when they fail to hold themselves to the same standards they demand of elected officials.
What if the major news media are controlled not by an outside force, but, as conservatives have long complained, by a systemic bias that, unaddressed, has festered and culminated in the current open hostilities?
Over the past 30 years, I’ve worked for four newspapers in three cities, and most of the journalists I’ve met have been decent, hardworking people who love their communities and country. These positive attributes are less prevalent, researchers say, in journalism’s higher echelons, where ambition, rootlessness and big money distort both character and product.
Documentation of the chasm between the average American and the average member of the coastal media elite began post-Watergate when technology changed journalism from a vast corps of “ink-stained wretches” to a small cadre of blow-dried TV stars. Their baby-boomer political sensibilities, unchecked, directly facilitated the rise of talk radio, Fox News and today’s myriad partisan websites.
The culture war and media war are inseparable. As we are seeing, both sides lose. I don’t know what the solution is, but if the warfare continues, it won’t lead anywhere good.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.