It was early enough in January that I could still say “Happy New Year,” and the couple, whom I know only slightly, sort of tag-teamed their response:
“Sure hope so!” “Last year was pretty bad, wasn’t it.” “Well, it was for us … .” They seemed to hesitate and add that last bit just in case I didn’t share their view and had actually enjoyed 2017.
I smiled with appreciation, saying, “That’s why we have to hold onto joyful things, right?”
It was their turn to smile. “Yes — like tonight!” And we headed into a great concert together.
That exchange sprang back to mind a few days ago when I received a reader’s thought-provoking email about a perceived shift in my column topics. I pondered it for days, wondering how correct his assessment was (of my work and of himself) and whether he had touched on something, like the couple at the concert, much broader than just the two of us.
He wrote: “Before” — before what? — “your columns were most always political in nature, [but] lately I see no politics in anything you write about.
“We differ enormously in our political beliefs,” he continued, “and because of that I could not read 99% of what you wrote, even though I think you are an excellent writer. Now I enjoy your column a great deal.
“Why have you changed your subject matter?”
Have I? If I have, am I the only one? Have a lot of us changed topics and perhaps our tone in recent months?
I asked my correspondent what point in time divided “before” from after. He “honestly can’t say” — that’s fair — but I had a hunch, and as I looked over the running list of finished column topics I’ve kept in my planner since January 2015, I was not surprised to see that a slow shift began in mid-2016.
The 2016 presidential campaign was so perplexing and off-putting that I recoiled from it as it unfolded. Donald Trump’s surprising victory, though, has divided the nation into three camps, not two: the dismayed (like me), the triumphant and the “resistance.”
We dismayed citizens have detached quite a bit from the news cycle and the exhausting pace of political back-and-forth.
Both the triumphant and the resisters are furious. Political ideas, their pursuit and practice — what I loved to write about — have been buried under a never-ending flood of bile. I have always known that politics will not save us, but now it seems we cannot save our politics.
I did not think that in my lifetime I would see the level of venom surpass what we experienced during the Iraq War and second Bush term, but I was wrong. What we have more than ever before is politics as slaughter.
I wade in only when I can summon the heart for it and think I might have some small insight to add.
But I disagree with my correspondent on one important principle. It is important to read and listen to people with whom we know we are likely to disagree. Well, not if they’re boring, inarticulate or lazy thinkers. Life is too short.
The partisan echo chambers online and on television have contributed mightily to stoking anger on each side. Sorting through the propaganda is exhausting, but crossing into “enemy territory” may help us hear across the divide and stir us to greater thought. It exposes us to facts that we would not otherwise encounter.
Through my 17 years at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, I have tried to offer a viewpoint that offsets the left-leaning editorial board and columnists’ lineup. But coming from a moderate Republican Midwestern family and the evangelical Christian world, I find myself challenging most of my friends and loved ones from their left.
I’m a contrarian. And I think I can make a very good case that the contrarian’s calling these days is to find or forge, if necessary, common ground.
If we want to live the examined life, to not conform unthinkingly to the spirit of our age, especially when it is as shallow, angry and deceitful as this one, then we have to respond by celebrating whatever is lasting, beautiful and true.
Sometimes we’ll have a necessary battle of ideas on our way to the lasting, beautiful and true, but I promise you that it will not be a battle just for the sake of fighting. Enough of that.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.