Before the chaos spreads southward, let’s contemplate something that’s happening in Canada.

A parent in British Columbia named Kori Doty is fighting authorities to obtain a birth certificate that does not identify the sex of an infant named Searyl Atli.

Canadian law requires that a birth certificate list a newborn’s sex, but the parent, who gave birth to the child in November, does not identify as either male or female, uses “they” and “their” to refer to individuals in a gender-neutral way and wants their child to grow up to be “the most whole person they can be.”

It is this newspaper’s style to use titles such as Mr. and Ms. after the first use of the person’s full name, to say nothing of agreement between subjects and verbs, but here, in my fourth sentence, I am unable to proceed as required. These grammatical and stylistic stumbling blocks are part and parcel of the bigger social challenge looming.

Advertise with us

If one were to point out that Kori Doty’s having given birth to Searyl indicates that they are a woman, one would risk being called a hater.

For the record, my initial astonishment at this story gave way quickly to a bemused sadness, but not hate. I do believe that Kori Doty, though thoughtful and well-spoken, is wrong-headed and that forcing this choice upon a voiceless child is a form of abuse.

Eight adults petitioning to change their own birth certificates is one thing, but if little Searyl goes out into the world without knowing his or her sex, he/​she has some searing days ahead. (Sometimes parents’ preventive measures create more pain than the dreaded problem would have.)

Nonetheless, I expect this trend to grow and a confused public to accommodate it. We are already at the point where calm, rational discussion of such complex issues is nearly impossible.

It doesn’t help the cause of rationality that media outlets covering this story such as the Canadian Broadcasting Corp. and Newsweek use the terms “sex” and “gender” interchangeably and therefore inaccurately.

Advertise with us

Sex is a genetic and anatomical fact. The vast majority of human beings are born with either XX or XY chromosomes, and in the vast majority of cases, their anatomical features match their DNA.

Gender is a more complicated term that encompasses social roles and personal identity. When a person’s sense of self does not coincide with his or her genetic sex, he or she may prefer to identify as transgender, may choose new pronouns and may opt for surgery to reconcile anatomy with identity.

Babies cannot do this.

Transgender is not the same as “gender free,” though. Some transgender people identify wholly and happily with one sex. Kori Doty, by contrast, who gave birth to Searyl but has a mustache and beard, rejects binary sex classifications and is a member of the Gender-Free ID Coalition.

Is this the latest battle in the unceasing “culture war”? If so, it’s off to a painful start. Every cause has its impassioned warriors, but usually when adults go to battle, they do not send their children in ahead to set off the landmines.

Advertise with us

If the Gender-Free ID Coalition wants official documents to have a third choice — how about “U” for “undeclared” — in addition to “F” and “M,” society may gradually move toward this accommodation, one registration form at a time.

But if they want a society in which sex is never identified or settled and gender roles are constantly in flux, then I will oppose them. This is individualism run amok.

If they want news stories to refer to a gender-free individual as “they” rather than “he” or “she,” then the media will have to rewrite their stylebooks. Confusion and redundancy will still ensue; I rewrote many sentences in this column a half-dozen times to adjust the English language for one dissenter.

But if we employ the new grammar only for stories about gender-free people, and not for all people, will that accommodation then be pronounced inadequate since “separate is not equal”?

Ah, the old slippery slope.

Advertise with us

For human beings to function as individuals, we process an enormous amount of information each day. We do it by sorting and classification. There is no classification more basic than sex.

For human beings to function in large groups, these classifications and norms have to be widely acknowledged and accepted. Doing so is not discrimination. It is reasonable, if done with mutual respect.

But we can make reasonable accommodation to dissenters and call a truce before the culture war heats up. Maybe this way, we can prevent children from being forced into the fray.

Ruth Ann Dai­ley: ruth­an­n­dai­ley@hot­mail.com