If you didn’t already know better, you’d assume that the case of Rachel Dolezal is a parody.

A blue-eyed, straight-haired blond teenager who as an adult now sports an ombre afro and slathers on the skin bronzer, the better to pass as a mixed-race leader in the NAACP?

It sounds like the distaff version of a Steve Martin movie. “I was born a poor black child …”

Ms. Dolezal’s Caucasian parents say she was born white — and still is.

Advertise with us

Her case couldn’t have come at a more cringe-worthy moment. It had been barely a week since Caitlyn Jenner — once known as Olympic athlete Bruce Jenner — made her sexy debut on the cover of Vanity Fair. (More unwitting parody in that choice of magazine title?)

Plenty of liberals are decrying Ms. Dolezal’s “black-face” impersonation, while other critics are taking aim at those so-called liberals, whose decades of “identity politics” have seemingly found their reduction-to-absurdity in Ms. Dolezal: I am who I say I am, the facts be damned.

Some conservatives are flipping the argument to another purpose, asking, like this headline at The Federalist website: “If Rachel Dolezal isn’t black, how is Caitlyn Jenner a woman?”

No matter which way you come at it, this is one giant train wreck of our society’s glorification of rabid individualism and the modern insistence, in some quarters, that “the personal is political.”

An obsession with your own identity is an important, awkward and frequently obnoxious phase of adolescence. But adolescence is a period you hopefully mature out of.

Advertise with us

Not us. We’ve been stuck in this phase for about 50 years — far too long to be healthy. This obsession has turned our public conversation and our politics into a circus — some would say “freak show” — making the calm consideration of serious ideas and true character ever less likely.

Or, in the hands of some politicians and celebrities, creating a welcome distraction from their lack of ideas and integrity.

When Elizabeth Warren, a woman of intellect and achievement, emerged on the national stage in 2012 as the Democratic candidate to unseat Sen. Scott Brown of Massachusetts, reporters had a field day with her “minority” faculty status at Harvard Law School.

The blue-eyed, snub-nosed Oklahoman claimed to be part Native American — allegedly only after having been hired, but thus helping the university with its diversity goals and probably helping her own advancement. It seemed both self-serving and ridiculous, undermining her credibility.

The woman she won’t run against, Hillary Clinton, was scheduled to roll out a new campaign strategy over the weekend that portrays her as the daughter of a woman, Dorothy Rodham, who was twice abandoned by her parents as a child and who worked much of her life as a maid.

Advertise with us

It is tough for a multimillionaire former secretary of state sitting atop a lavishly funded but stingy “nonprofit” foundation to find a way to present herself as one of life’s victims. “I was the daughter of a poor white maid” is as close as Mrs. Clinton is going to get.

This new narrative, however, goes far to explain her insatiable lust for money and to distract from her poor record.

In a presidential race where NBC dubs Mrs. Clinton the “titan” to beat, the only other candidate with a better identity-based narrative is Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida. Is it any coincidence that as Mrs. Clinton’s serious scandals dragged on, The New York Times roughed up Republican Sen. Rubio and his wife twice in one week for a few traffic citations and for buying an $80,000 fishing boat?

If you’re rooting for the first female president, despite her having enough baggage to sink a battleship, you’re going to have to attach baggage to her foremost “identity” rival, the fresher, less scandal-ridden Cuban-American.

God forbid we hear and compare their ideas. In politics, identity issues are usually more about manipulation than authenticity.

Advertise with us

Is that true outside the drama of politics? Are Rachel Dolezal and Caitlyn Jenner in search of authentic selves, or are they manipulating a system for influence, attention or money?

Are there mental health issues involved? If so, at what point do biological facts matter?

Philosophers, psychiatrists and “anti-psychiatrists” have been debating such profundities for years. Like us, they struggle to balance accountability with compassion.

The only sure thing is that the narratives we tell about ourselves are of the utmost importance. They shape our characters and destinies — individually and collectively — and as seems clearer every day, they may even shape our sanity.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.