In recent weeks, the Federal Communications Commission has taken an increasingly aggressive — and critical — interest in professional sports’ streaming strategies, and whether they’re putting games out of reach for too many people.

On Major League Baseball’s Opening Night a couple of weeks ago, fans needed Netflix to stream the Yankees game. Don’t have Netflix? Enjoy the highlights.

Last season, The Athletic estimated that football fans need at least four subscriptions and more than $600 to watch their team and national broadcasts such as Thursday Night Football.

Why you now can’t see every game

This is the result of the Sports Broadcasting Act, a 1961 law that now makes it harder for millions of fans to enjoy games. A league’s teams pooling broadcasting rights made sense then. It helped leagues bring consistency and national reach to viewers. That law made sense in a three-network, black-and-white television world.

Advertise with us

But it doesn’t any more. In today’s fractured streaming marketplace, the 1961 model has clearly outlived its purpose, when the pool sells the rights to many different streamers. Now fans are paying more for less.

How did this begin? In the earliest days of televised football in the 1940s, teams sold their own broadcasting rights, rewarding big-market franchises and threatening to marginalize smaller ones. The National Football League’s response was to limit competition.

It barred teams from broadcasting into another club’s home market in 1951. Ten years later, it went further and gathered all team rights into a single package sold to CBS.

The concept was transformative. With one deal, the league could turn a shaggy collection of unequal teams into a single national product. Equal sharing of television revenue enabled a small-market team like the Green Bay Packers to compete with the New York Giants.

Congress supported the leagues and viewers

To regulators, however, the deal looked less like innovation and more like cartel behavior and they nixed it. The NFL took its case to Congress and secured the Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961.

Advertise with us

Professional baseball, basketball, hockey and football teams could now pool their broadcast rights and sell them collectively. This sparked a fundamental change in how fans experienced sports.

For the first time, leagues could bring consistent broadcasts to households, free and over the air. Sunday night games became a shared national experience, and the NFL was on its way to becoming a cultural juggernaut.

The benefits to the league were huge. In 1962, it signed a two-year deal with CBS for $9.3 million. Six decades later, the league signed a set of TV and streaming agreements that will bring in around $110 billion over 11 seasons. And that figure is unlikely to be the ceiling: The league has already signaled it will opt out early to negotiate a more lucrative deal.

Good — nay, great — for the league, bad for the fans.

The Sports Broadcasting Act was designed for advertiser-supported broadcast television, not today’s app-driven ecosystem with paid tiers. As the league divides its games across a growing number of services, competing platforms drive up rights fees — and inevitably those costs are passed down to subscribers. The shared national experience is also suffering, splintered across nickel-and-diming paywalls.

Advertise with us

The FCC may help viewers, or not

To be fair, the NFL still ensures that fans in local markets can watch their team’s games for free over the air. The NBA, MLB and NHL don’t make any such promises. But that narrow slice is a reminder of just how far the system has drifted.

It felt like a touchdown for fans when the FCC launched an investigation into the migration of sports away from free TV. The stakes for the leagues are significant. Speaking to Fox & Friends Weekend recently, FCC chairman Brendan Carr mused about the leagues and whether paywalls “undermine their ability to claim that antitrust exemption.”

What happens next is uncertain. The FCC has oversight over broadcasters, not leagues or streaming platforms (for now), so its power to directly alter the sports media market is limited. (Under the Biden administration, the FCC said it didn’t have authority over streamers and that any change would need to come from Congress. The Trump administration hasn’t reversed that finding, but some legal analysts have labeled the FCC’s position as “untested.”)

But the FCC is not powerless. The agency has gathered thousands of comments on streaming fragmentation and is using its public platform to highlight the issue. Both actions could create momentum for the Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission to launch their own investigations and pursue antitrust cases.

Congress can help the viewers, but may not

The greater threat to the leagues is Congress, with its repealing power. But simply doing away with the Sports Broadcasting Act risks making things worse. If individual teams have to cut their own media deals, consumers will likely face an even more fragmented market for watching their favorite teams.

Advertise with us

A better answer is to update the act. Congress could require, for example, that a meaningful share of a league’s matchups — and not just a local market’s home games — remain available on free or widely accessible platforms (that would still buy rights from the leagues).

Such a move would help preserve sports as one of America’s few shared cultural experiences, while allowing the leagues to continue to profit from the privilege of an antitrust exemption.

That balance once worked: Fans got football and leagues got rich. It’s time to modernize the deal for the streaming age.

Adam Minter is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist and author of “Secondhand: Travels in the New Global Garage Sale." His previous article was “Curling may be the answer to America's future Olympic problems.”